I grew up loving Foo. My opinion is pretty consistent with some here. 2005 and 2007 albums are where I kinda checked out since they’re fine at best. Wasting Light is a monster. Every album after that has maybe 1-2 songs that are pretty solid songs. Most are fine. I don’t want to rip my ears off or anything.
They’re not overly adventurous in the sense of The Beatles or anything, but they do what they do well. That’s okay. They’re not writing the same songs they wrote in 1997 still.
There’s very much an, “if I don’t love it, it sucks!” mentality on this forum. Feels like some of you should learn what, “not for me,” means.