Jump to content

Coma16

Members
  • Posts

    9,470
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Posts posted by Coma16

  1. 1 hour ago, janrichmond said:

    I would presume it's because they're not touring.

    Maybe, but there's 2 St Paul (peanuts) just collecting dust on ebay - one of them didn't get any bites at $500 during a week-long auction. There are multiple fire sales at the moment. Good time for new collectors to get in the game (assuming that perceived values will increase when they get back on the road). Also, will they continue doing lithos in the future? Who would take it on (assuming Fernango got the corn)?

  2. 13 hours ago, evilfacelessturtle said:

    Jesus Christ, that pitch correction fuck up at 1:19 is horrible. How did they let those kinds of fuck ups onto the final album?

    There are many overreactions to this album, and this criticism (which is hardly noticeable to regular people) is high up there imo

  3. 15 hours ago, Scream of the Butterfly said:

    Surprised to hear the Perhaps video was received so well around here. I watched it around the time it came out and about two seconds in I immediately thought people were going to hate it!

    It was a more appealing song, which certainly helped. Plus, it was all (basically) released at the same time too, so the overall experience was different.

  4. 2 minutes ago, Sweersa said:

    I agree. Overall I like Monsters a lot more over The General. Aside from poor production on both songs (especially The General), my main gripe with Monsters (aside from it not being a CD-era mix with Buckethead, of course) is the chorus seems to occur too quickly in the song. In other words, I wish the verses were a little longer. It almost feels rushed. But, that's me being nitpicky and probably comes from me expecting Soul Monster was a longer song that it actually was. 

    I wonder if they have any longer songs (~6 minutes or longer) left in the can. Like the Sorry, Prostitute or There Was A Time of CD2 from a song length standpoint. 

    Most, if not all the CD2 stuff we got (leaked or released) with vocals are around 4 minutes. 

    Elvis is nearly 6 minutes. Dummy is over 6 minutes but that seems more like an outline/idea than a song.

    • Like 1
  5. 5 minutes ago, colonizedmind said:

    It's interesting more between the two tracks...

    I still think it's of note that despite not being connected in sequence (that we know of at this point) they share the same Marco B bed of music that used to intro the shows....so, either Axl's brief was similar for both tracks or if on an album, they could follow each other...

    Belltrami's other orchestration on CD tracks is quite different, so it's an interest thing to dwell on, amongst the myriad of other endless questions 

    Rather than back-to-back I think a better idea would be if they were opening (TG) and closing (Monsters) tracks on a full length album (lol)

  6. 3 hours ago, GnR Chris said:

    I don’t get why people keep saying stuff like “after all the hype and lore, I can’t believe how disappointing ‘The General’ is.” ‘Cause really, the song we thought was “The General” is actual “Monsters.” And that song is dope as fuck. TBH though, I enjoy both songs. But “Monsters” is obviously more accessible. 

    Somewhat revisionist. The General was mythical before Evador, Cell Phone recording, and GNR Twitter commment. But agree about rest.

  7. 21 hours ago, WhazUp said:

    Regarding why Monsters was leaked alongside The General, not that I think they are the same song like the way Rocket Queen's two sections are but I do still have a theory of them being linked in some way

    Like, maybe they were originally side-by-side on the followup to CD or something and were meant to be played one after the other.  Both have Beltrami orchestration and you can easily interpret the lyrics to Monsters as some anger and then closure to The General

     

    I think it would work better as an album (lol) opener and the Monsters to close the fictitious album 

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...