AtlasShrugged

Will someone ask Carrie if she's heard the unreleased songs and if she thinks the Village leaks versions were stronger

Frank

Probably won't make a difference yeah but it's the possible bit of publicity that may make people go.. I wonder are they playing near me. Can't see it moving the dial too much though

It is weird how often she features in the band's content. And other family members - they mean nothing to anybody outside a handful of fans. Just strange. Could argue that for the WAGs too.

Scours the internet for more leaks

Strong feeling they have been saving Perhaps for this show

We need to stop talking about 'days' that they may or may not do something. There is clearly no rhyme to it with GN'R. Might come tomorrow, might come on a Friday in a month. Nobody knows and we won't be able to predict it.

What for?

Doubt it - this was done in advance of Paris and he may not even know he was being recorded. Plus if it was planned, GN'R couldn't have known for sure this would get out.

Do we not already know from what Slash said that the 4-6 Chi Dem songs have already been redone? Ie, Absurd, HS, Perhaps and (likely The General)? So when he says about music next year, they wouldn't need to work on the songs they've already done - so implies it's separate from that.

Yeah but we know the 4-6 has already been done. So seems to me like it's something different to that next year.

Well at the least it sounds like there's more to it than Slash's initial 4-6. Implies we might get a new single in the next week or two (Perhaps, perhaps) and then they've been working on other stuff that they'll get finished or whatever next year. God knows what form the latter is though.. is it new.. is it old recordings. In any case, it's the most we've got about actual plans in a while.

It'll be on iPlayer for a few more weeks. Worth just ripping it from there and keeping yourself. Will probably be on YouTube by fans at various points

Well, that's why I said we'll agree to disagree. In my view, he deliberately twists the question in his answer which I find condescending. We've talked about his replies before, you obviously have a different reading of it than I do - no point in us going back and forth.

There are countless examples of him being vague or condescending to people who ask about it. Think we've had this discussion before (which we can agree to disagree on again!) I just find his tone to fans condescending. Fans are entitled to ask, he can just ignore it rather than trying to make a sarcastic comment about it.

He is so arrogant. He always does this. What does he expect? Fans are allowed an opinion.

Jeez. Two of my favourite songs and I hadn't noticed that!

Being quiet here during a show is the way it should be. Not ideal for us but fans should be let enjoy the show in person. It's obviously appreciated but Jesus sitting streaming a show for 100 people on the internet is such a waste. If they don't record Perhaps, though, I'll have a problem...

IT'S SO EASY!

Seems to be a good one starting here. When there's no-one left blame

Could guess they'll perform Perhaps at any number of shows for any number of reasons. Glastonbury was a good shout as such a big event but reality is it will happen when it happens.. there'll likely not be any rhyme or reason. Fingers crossed it's tonight though lol

Brilliant stuff. Hope we get it. Close either way!

Actually coming up now. Bizarre

I can see two shorts for GN'R on two separate BBC channels but not full songs. VPN has been in and out so could well be a problem on my side. Anyway, no odds to me as I can watch on iPlayer, was just an observation!

Ah - not available in my country. I'm in between VPNs from yesterday so god knows what's going on!