If there was ever a reunion of the AFD or UYI lineup....

[liers]

It's unlikely, but let's say there was a reunion of the AFD or UYI lineup. Slash comes back, Duff comes back, Izzy comes back, and Steven or Matt comes back, Dizzy and Pitman stay, but everyone else is out, except for one thing.... the second guitarist. Who out of the 3 we have would you want to stay? Fortus, Bumblefoot, or Ashba?

[Guest Len B'stard]

Neither...Bumbles way too good to sit on rhythm and i can't see Slash handing lead to him, Ashba is an embarassment and Fortus is...certainly not bad or an embarassment but he's kinda...lacking something. There's something by the numbers about him, he doesn't set my world alight. And anyway, why would you need a second guitarist?

[liers]

Neither...Bumbles way too good to sit on rhythm and i can't see Slash handing lead to him, Ashba is an embarassment and Fortus is...certainly not bad or an embarassment but he's kinda...lacking something. There's something by the numbers about him, he doesn't set my world alight. And anyway, why would you need a second guitarist?

Your really don't need a second guitarist. You don't need two keyboardist either, but for whatever reason Axl wants two of everything (Remember, he wanted Brain to come back and drum with Frank too). The band was set to be a one guitar band in 2004, but then Axl brought in Bumble, so he's pretty determined to have a 2 guitar lineup for some reason.

It wouldn't be a rhythm spot, that would be Izzy, it would be a second lead like they have now.

[Guest Len B'stard]

Well if you don't need it, leave it, lets face it, it's hardly done the sound any favours, has it? And if you're having a reunion then why drag aspects of NuGnr into the original?

[supercool]

slash, gilby and izzy

fuck the nugnr boys

[ShadowOfTheWave]

I'd pick Fortus. Bumble's the best but I don't think they'd mesh as well. DJ is worthless.

[sweetness]

Null vote.

[Scumcat Esq.]

I'd go with the one and only DJ Ashba! Now that would be fun!

[The Glow Inc.]

Richard Fortus.

Slash wanted him in his band so I suppose it would work.

[vaida]

None would be my choice..

[Scumcat Esq.]

None would be my choice..

Would you leave poor Slash to handle it all all by himself?

Edited February 13, 2014 by Scumcat Esq.

[Apollo]

None.

Tthey don't need three guitar players to perform the role of two guys.

Two guitars worked pretty well on Appetite, Lies and the Illusions. Go back to that formula.

[Scumcat Esq.]

Alice Cooper has no probs performing with three guitarists.

[Bards]

Nobody. a 3rd guitar player is superfluous in the new band, let alone the old band.

[DieselDaisy]

Stick with two guitars.

[Nosaj Thing]

Fortus would be the best fit.

[Crash Diet]

It's unlikely, but let's say there was a reunion of the AFD or UYI lineup. Slash comes back, Duff comes back, Izzy comes back, and Steven or Matt comes back, Dizzy and Pitman stay, but everyone else is out, except for one thing.... the second guitarist. Who out of the 3 we have would you want to stay? Fortus, Bumblefoot, or Ashba?

In this case 4tus

This means we got 2 Izzy's in the band

[DieselDaisy]

It would just seem weird having newgnr members in a reunited line-up: Slash turning to Izzy, ''who is this dick (Pitman)? I do not remember him when we played the Roxy in '86''.

[moreblack]

Slash and Izzy, don't need nobody else.

[Scumcat Esq.]

It's unlikely, but let's say there was a reunion of the AFD or UYI lineup. Slash comes back, Duff comes back, Izzy comes back, and Steven or Matt comes back, Dizzy and Pitman stay, but everyone else is out, except for one thing.... the second guitarist. Who out of the 3 we have would you want to stay? Fortus, Bumblefoot, or Ashba?

In this case 4tus

This means we got 2 Izzy's in the band

The more the merrier!

[SlashisGOD]

If you just have to have 3 guitar players, then only Gilby of course.

[Apollo]

To be honest, I don't really care who is in the band.........just as long as Axl was releasing music.

[gunnari]

Option: NONE!!!

[Patience 4 Axl]

I like Fortus. Of all the new members, he's by far the most tolerable. But if there's a reunion, I don't want or need any of the session employees to be a part of the band.