Jump to content

2414225

Members
  • Posts

    252
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by 2414225

  1. 1 hour ago, liers said:

    The only CD era songs that the old band worked on were possibly This I Love and Oh My God. All did parts of TIL on the piano in 1993 and I'm pretty sure Duff and Matt heard OMG but "failed to see its potential."

    Potential? This song is horrible and doesn't sound like GnR at all. Since Duff said they worked on a song for a Jackie Chan movie back then, I think, 'Checkmate' was one of o few CD songs Duff and Matt knew about. 

    IMO Cure me or kill me, Beggars and hangers on, Back to the moment, Fall to pieces, Slither, Set me free, etc were songs considered for the post UYI era. These songs simply sounds like GnR. And since Axl didn't want to put lyrics on them, they did it with some other voices. 

  2. 2 hours ago, Kasanova King said:

    More or less this.  Fortus is a better fit than Gilby was for sure but he's no Izzy.

    I have nothing personal against Fortus, but could you guys just stop the myth that he is a great guitarist? The truth is, he has no credits on Chinese Democracy or any other pop/rock track. The only memorable guitar work of him, I know,  is this:

    Which is a bit weird... IMO his and Frank's style doesn't fit with Slash's, while Gilby's style fits perfectly. Plus, Gilby can carry an audience. 

    Richard should join Enrique Iglesias again:

     

    • Like 3
  3. 30 minutes ago, Hollywood Gunner said:

    richards a great musician but he'll never EVER be able to fill izzys shoes. i personally never even compare the two. ive always seen richard as a great fill in for gilby

    Frank, 4tus and Melissa are just in the band because they are cheaper and Axl has more supporters around him. We will never get a AFD and UYI reunion tour, because there would be always a 1:4 veto when it comes to important band direction questions.  

    • Like 2
  4. 5 hours ago, xBrownstonex said:

    Dont flatter yourself. Trolls like you don't offend me. I just find it hilarious that you constantly try to make judgments that you couldn't possible be serious about, unless you're just here to troll or live in an absolute fantasy world. I think for you both apply. You can say slash looks bored as much as you want, but its just ridiculous and has nothing to do with honesty or whatever the fuck. 

    Have you ever heard about the freedom of speech, Merkel-boy? You're living in your own fantasy world...GnR has to compare themselves with themselves from the past. GnR's curse is that they delivered on almost every show between 86-93. 

    I'm ok with the fact that Axl's current voice won't reach the old one. But it's only acceptable for me if the rest of the band is fine. It was a totally different vibe when Adler was on drums in 2016. Fortus and Ferrer can't reach the level of perfection GnR stand for between 86-93.

    If you don't hear that, you're simply fine with every GnR transformation. Imagine a Beatles tour without Lennon and Ringo and a different Paul voice. Would you be fine with that? Well, I think you would, but I wouldn't. 

    And the next problem is: Izzy, Adler, Matt and Gilby are as bitter as every 'hater' here. So saying that we're all just a couple of negative party crashers is just bollocks. We are just defenders of their glorious past. 

  5. 3 minutes ago, estrangedtwat said:

    Ah Christ.

     

    Some people are never fucking satisfied.

    Dude, you can't deny the facts. Adler, Izzy, Matt and Gilby ain't satisfied as well. So it's obvious that a lot of fans ain't happy with that farce tour, too.

    And yeah, I know... Pitman is bitter as well...but it's just Pitman. 

  6. 1 hour ago, xBrownstonex said:

    img_0085.jpg

    Wow, no FC Bayern, no Oktoberfest, no beer, Bratwurst, Dirndl and Lederhosen, no Frauenkirche, no Olympia Park, no BMW involved. 

    Neuschwanstein is pretty far away from Munich. But it could be hint that Axl will pay tribute to Mickey Mouse today. 

    • Like 3
  7. Chinese Democracy is a patchwork of many ideas, musicians and producers. None of these tracks sounds done. 

    Go in a studio, record a song, add some digital elements. Ok. 

    But every track on CD sounds like they edited a song 100 times. With tons of different musicians, cheap pitman elements, etc. It's better than Beach Boys Smile, but that's it. 

    Like DieselDaisy said, the first IRS leak sounded very interesting cause it had a blues vibe and wasn't edited that many times. 

    The ideas of CD were interesting in terms of an Axl solo record. It still completely failed as a good rock album. And it was blasphemy to label it as a GNR album. 

    The costs of 13+ million dollars crowns this disaster. 

     

     

×
×
  • Create New...