Jump to content

St. Jakobshalle, Basel/Switzerland


Silent Jay

Recommended Posts

They choose not to.

unfortunetly this is true

I don't know why they choose not to, he seems so happy & friendly. What fan wouldn't want to be there taking photos & joking with him like this? :thumbsup:

people who blame him for not fullfilling their reunion fantasies

bran-

2 b fair.....slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum thought axl would accept the guns n roses HOF induction and perform guns n roses classics at HOF with them

axl plays guns n roses classics every night around the world. on the 29th show on the 2012 summer leg of the chinese democracy world wide tour........axl performed 15 slash classic hits. only performed 6 chinese democracy songs post slash from robin and bucket

whether axl plays the classics at 2012 guns n roses concerts or with slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum at guns n roses HOF

what's the difference? guns n roses classics is guns n roses classics. no different. it's the same

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 152
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

They choose not to.

unfortunetly this is true

I don't know why they choose not to, he seems so happy & friendly. What fan wouldn't want to be there taking photos & joking with him like this? :thumbsup:

people who blame him for not fullfilling their reunion fantasies

bran-

2 b fair.....slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum thought axl would accept the guns n roses HOF induction and perform guns n roses classics at HOF with them

axl plays guns n roses classics every night around the world. on the 29th show on the 2012 summer leg of the chinese democracy world wide tour........axl performed 15 slash classic hits. only performed 6 chinese democracy songs post slash from robin and bucket

whether axl plays the classics at 2012 guns n roses concerts or with slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum at guns n roses HOF

what's the difference? guns n roses classics is guns n roses classics. no different. it's the same

why would axl stop playing songs he wrote?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They choose not to.

unfortunetly this is true

I don't know why they choose not to, he seems so happy & friendly. What fan wouldn't want to be there taking photos & joking with him like this? :thumbsup:

people who blame him for not fullfilling their reunion fantasies

bran-

2 b fair.....slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum thought axl would accept the guns n roses HOF induction and perform guns n roses classics at HOF with them

axl plays guns n roses classics every night around the world. on the 29th show on the 2012 summer leg of the chinese democracy world wide tour........axl performed 15 slash classic hits. only performed 6 chinese democracy songs post slash from robin and bucket

whether axl plays the classics at 2012 guns n roses concerts or with slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum at guns n roses HOF

what's the difference? guns n roses classics is guns n roses classics. no different. it's the same

why would axl stop playing songs he wrote?

because slash is out. dj ashba and ron thal is in

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They choose not to.

unfortunetly this is true

I don't know why they choose not to, he seems so happy & friendly. What fan wouldn't want to be there taking photos & joking with him like this? :thumbsup:

people who blame him for not fullfilling their reunion fantasies

bran-

2 b fair.....slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum thought axl would accept the guns n roses HOF induction and perform guns n roses classics at HOF with them

axl plays guns n roses classics every night around the world. on the 29th show on the 2012 summer leg of the chinese democracy world wide tour........axl performed 15 slash classic hits. only performed 6 chinese democracy songs post slash from robin and bucket

whether axl plays the classics at 2012 guns n roses concerts or with slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum at guns n roses HOF

what's the difference? guns n roses classics is guns n roses classics. no different. it's the same

why would axl stop playing songs he wrote?

because slash is out. dj ashba and ron thal is in

you do know how stupid that sounds right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They choose not to.

unfortunetly this is true

I don't know why they choose not to, he seems so happy & friendly. What fan wouldn't want to be there taking photos & joking with him like this? :thumbsup:

people who blame him for not fullfilling their reunion fantasies

bran-

2 b fair.....slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum thought axl would accept the guns n roses HOF induction and perform guns n roses classics at HOF with them

axl plays guns n roses classics every night around the world. on the 29th show on the 2012 summer leg of the chinese democracy world wide tour........axl performed 15 slash classic hits. only performed 6 chinese democracy songs post slash from robin and bucket

whether axl plays the classics at 2012 guns n roses concerts or with slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum at guns n roses HOF

what's the difference? guns n roses classics is guns n roses classics. no different. it's the same

why would axl stop playing songs he wrote?

because slash is out. dj ashba and ron thal is in

you do know how stupid that sounds right?

it sounds spot on 2 me. if slash was in 2012 guns n roses.....i'd have no problem with axl playing 15 classic guns n roses hits over new guns n roses songs. but slash isn't in the band. dj ashba and ron thal is in the band. so i have a problem with axl playing classic hits over new material. classic hits dj ashba and ron thal are not a part of

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They choose not to.

unfortunetly this is true

I don't know why they choose not to, he seems so happy & friendly. What fan wouldn't want to be there taking photos & joking with him like this? :thumbsup:

people who blame him for not fullfilling their reunion fantasies

bran-

2 b fair.....slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum thought axl would accept the guns n roses HOF induction and perform guns n roses classics at HOF with them

axl plays guns n roses classics every night around the world. on the 29th show on the 2012 summer leg of the chinese democracy world wide tour........axl performed 15 slash classic hits. only performed 6 chinese democracy songs post slash from robin and bucket

whether axl plays the classics at 2012 guns n roses concerts or with slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum at guns n roses HOF

what's the difference? guns n roses classics is guns n roses classics. no different. it's the same

why would axl stop playing songs he wrote?

because slash is out. dj ashba and ron thal is in

you do know how stupid that sounds right?

it sounds spot on 2 me. if slash was in 2012 guns n roses.....i'd have no problem with axl playing 15 classic guns n roses hits over new guns n roses songs. but slash isn't in the band. dj ashba and ron thal is in the band. so i have a problem with axl playing classic hits over new material. classic hits dj ashba and ron thal are not a part of

if that sounds right to you i would suggest getting your hearing checked

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They choose not to.

unfortunetly this is true

I don't know why they choose not to, he seems so happy & friendly. What fan wouldn't want to be there taking photos & joking with him like this? :thumbsup:

people who blame him for not fullfilling their reunion fantasies

bran-

2 b fair.....slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum thought axl would accept the guns n roses HOF induction and perform guns n roses classics at HOF with them

axl plays guns n roses classics every night around the world. on the 29th show on the 2012 summer leg of the chinese democracy world wide tour........axl performed 15 slash classic hits. only performed 6 chinese democracy songs post slash from robin and bucket

whether axl plays the classics at 2012 guns n roses concerts or with slash, duff, steven, and matt sorum at guns n roses HOF

what's the difference? guns n roses classics is guns n roses classics. no different. it's the same

why would axl stop playing songs he wrote?

because slash is out. dj ashba and ron thal is in

you do know how stupid that sounds right?

it sounds spot on 2 me. if slash was in 2012 guns n roses.....i'd have no problem with axl playing 15 classic guns n roses hits over new guns n roses songs. but slash isn't in the band. dj ashba and ron thal is in the band. so i have a problem with axl playing classic hits over new material. classic hits dj ashba and ron thal are not a part of

if that sounds right to you i would suggest getting your hearing checked

my hearing's fine, bran

what i say is fact. on the june 29th 2012 guns n roses world wide concert on the chinese democracy world wide tour.....axl played 15 slash songs. and only played 6 robin/bucket chinese democracy songs

2012 guns n roses concerts showcase what slash written and recorded in guns n roses

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if your hearing is fine get a CAT scan

i don't need a CAT scan

if you think axl rose who wrote the songs he sings every night should stop them because slash isnt on stage with him that is just the dumbest shit i have ever seen.

Edited by bran
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel stupid for not hearing the mistake.

I kind of do too but on watching it again I could see he was supposed to slow down & stop but the music was still going which sort of forced him to continue singing.

Didn't the guitarists also muck it up too then, they kept on playing rather than stopping where they should have, if they stopped Frank would have been playing to nothing?

Axl comes in on the "C" rather than the "G" at the end. It sounds like he's coming in late, but I think since the entire band kept playing, he came in a few measures early and on the wrong beat.

The entire band (six of them?) would have had to somehow move the song ahead a couple beats without it sounding like a mistake.

Monitor issues probably. I find most of Axl's "screw ups" involve him being a couple beats off from the rest of the band, but technically doing his parts perfectly, so it must have to do with whatever's going into his ears.

I would love to hear what they are hearing in those earphones as I really don't understand how that helps them. Obviously it does as many musicians wear them, not being musically minded I will probably never understand. :shrugs:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if your hearing is fine get a CAT scan

i don't need a CAT scan

if you think axl rose who wrote the songs he sings every night should stop them because slash isnt on stage with him that is just the dumbest shit i have ever seen.

bran-

it's unfair 2 dj ashba and ron thal the fact axl keeps singing slash songs at guns n roses concerts world wide

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

good point KDH those are dennis stratton songs not steve harris songs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

good point KDH those are dennis stratton songs not steve harris songs

You don't even understand. Dennis hasn't been in the band in 30 years and Iron Maiden STILL plays his songs. Fuckin' hacks scabs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

i can't speak for iron maiden. but with guns n roses.....as long as dj ashba and ron thal in the band....you drop slash

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

good point KDH those are dennis stratton songs not steve harris songs

You don't even understand. Dennis hasn't been in the band in 30 years and Iron Maiden STILL plays his songs. Fuckin' hacks scabs.

i agree with you KDH i was being sarcastic toward finck6 lol

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

i can't speak for iron maiden. but with guns n roses.....as long as dj ashba and ron thal in the band....you drop slash

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HoaFWI5S0Q

Edited by bran
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

good point KDH those are dennis stratton songs not steve harris songs

You don't even understand. Dennis hasn't been in the band in 30 years and Iron Maiden STILL plays his songs. Fuckin' hacks scabs.

i agree with you KDH i was being sarcastic toward finck6 lol

I was being sarcastic, too. ;)

There are a lot of things you could pick at Axl with, but to say Axl doesn't have a right to play material he wrote is just lol-worthy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

good point KDH those are dennis stratton songs not steve harris songs

You don't even understand. Dennis hasn't been in the band in 30 years and Iron Maiden STILL plays his songs. Fuckin' hacks scabs.

i agree with you KDH i was being sarcastic toward finck6 lol

I was being sarcastic, too. ;)

There are a lot of things you could pick at Axl with, but to say Axl doesn't have a right to play material he wrote is just lol-worthy.

yeah it is i think he is just a bad cupcake or maybe he is 10 years old i dont know :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

i can't speak for iron maiden. but with guns n roses.....as long as dj ashba and ron thal in the band....you drop slash

Would you allow Finck and Bucket to play Slash's stuff on a daily basis? Because you seem to be cool with them playing old songs but somehow DJ and Ron cant. Even if they play the songs better. Yes, I said it...lol. I'm expecting you to go crazy now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Iron Maiden shouldn't do the song "Iron Maiden" anymore because Dennis Stratton, Clive Burr, and Paul Di'Anno aren't in the band anymore.

i can't speak for iron maiden. but with guns n roses.....as long as dj ashba and ron thal in the band....you drop slash

Would you allow Finck and Bucket to play Slash's stuff on a daily basis? Because you seem to be cool with them playing old songs but somehow DJ and Ron cant. Even if they play the songs better. Yes, I said it...lol. I'm expecting you to go crazy now.

axl makes finck and bucket and dj and a bumble play slash every night. if i was lead singer of guns n roses i wouldn't. i'd allow them to play what they've written and recorded with chinese democracy material only. it's fair to them. it's not fair always having to perform slash

i don't know how good dj and ron are at performing slash songs. but i know dj and ron should stop playing slash songs. and play their own guns n roses material

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bootleg :

1. CD : http://www.mediafire.com/?vmw68076788dodd

2. WTTJ : http://www.mediafire.com/?cdkzb53qf4mmu1g

3. It's : http://www.mediafire.com/?13an9a83edbnh0i

4. MB : http://www.mediafire.com/?f7vjoxfq9cb6xlc

5. Sorry : http://www.mediafire.com/?7930yvmu2ipmxcn

6. RQ : http://www.mediafire.com/?qkc9w78p6cnbowe

7. Estranged : http://www.mediafire.com/?qbxc6n64yytj4xa

8. Better : http://www.mediafire.com/?g5b59g28qah1b3q

9. Richard solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?9a4e82xan69zxkz

10. LALD : http://www.mediafire.com/?ezcofzrq1b39mt9

11. TIL : http://www.mediafire.com/?19abd314kba450n

12. SR : http://www.mediafire.com/?ftnterf3a22vxcj

13. Motivation : http://www.mediafire.com/?2zdk27d9cvdqef6

14. Intro. : http://www.mediafire.com/?z6it888p5pkdzok

15. Dizzy solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?ocml81l2iiab719

16. SOD : http://www.mediafire.com/?4q3de39btbd1ibo

17. YCBM : http://www.mediafire.com/?n7fk8ehb61n9pbh

18. DJ solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?qe2d940xc1ns2zu

19. SCOM : http://www.mediafire.com/?x7hlj5j4inpap5v

20. Band jam/Another brick… : http://www.mediafire.com/?j179bdajmfe5o83

21. Axl on piano : http://www.mediafire.com/?rqa45l54s9jshwg

22. NR : http://www.mediafire.com/?12smsdh21t17m88

23. GTBH : http://www.mediafire.com/?yqxmtvf1vq715gd

24. Ron solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?t2mx3pdqqh0mqyc

25. DC : http://www.mediafire.com/?bs9uxxg7s5icyyz

26. CW : http://www.mediafire.com/?w1d9uu5dkdpjxgp

27. KOHD : http://www.mediafire.com/?gsucjk2f1wwc8lr

28. Nightrain : http://www.mediafire.com/?m8nne94l3iabc6c

29. Jam : http://www.mediafire.com/?r3l313ojdb2p0cb

30. Madagascar : http://www.mediafire.com/?3inkj134saf2fr2

31. DF : http://www.mediafire.com/?f8la10cxvfv88c1

32. UTLH : http://www.mediafire.com/?ku2kznv8irkssg9

33. Band jam : http://www.mediafire.com/?ozz16vabiwc375h

34. Patience : http://www.mediafire.com/?dtil9kxn597bapr

35. Solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?rzgb07537u7a5wk

36. PC : http://www.mediafire.com/?q5qno6t0210d847

Not bad. Thanks to Carioca Ausländer.

Edited by Silent Jay
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bootleg :

1. CD : http://www.mediafire.com/?vmw68076788dodd

2. WTTJ : http://www.mediafire.com/?cdkzb53qf4mmu1g

3. It's : http://www.mediafire.com/?13an9a83edbnh0i

4. MB : http://www.mediafire.com/?f7vjoxfq9cb6xlc

5. Sorry : http://www.mediafire.com/?7930yvmu2ipmxcn

6. RQ : http://www.mediafire.com/?qkc9w78p6cnbowe

7. Estranged : http://www.mediafire.com/?qbxc6n64yytj4xa

8. Better : http://www.mediafire.com/?g5b59g28qah1b3q

9. Richard solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?9a4e82xan69zxkz

10. LALD : http://www.mediafire.com/?ezcofzrq1b39mt9

11. TIL : http://www.mediafire.com/?19abd314kba450n

12. SR : http://www.mediafire.com/?ftnterf3a22vxcj

13. Motivation : http://www.mediafire.com/?2zdk27d9cvdqef6

14. Intro. : http://www.mediafire.com/?z6it888p5pkdzok

15. Dizzy solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?ocml81l2iiab719

16. SOD : http://www.mediafire.com/?4q3de39btbd1ibo

17. YCBM : http://www.mediafire.com/?n7fk8ehb61n9pbh

18. DJ solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?qe2d940xc1ns2zu

19. SCOM : http://www.mediafire.com/?x7hlj5j4inpap5v

20. Band jam/Another brick… : http://www.mediafire.com/?j179bdajmfe5o83

21. Axl on piano : http://www.mediafire.com/?rqa45l54s9jshwg

22. NR : http://www.mediafire.com/?12smsdh21t17m88

23. GTBH : http://www.mediafire.com/?yqxmtvf1vq715gd

24. Ron solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?t2mx3pdqqh0mqyc

25. DC : http://www.mediafire.com/?bs9uxxg7s5icyyz

26. CW : http://www.mediafire.com/?w1d9uu5dkdpjxgp

27. KOHD : http://www.mediafire.com/?gsucjk2f1wwc8lr

28. Nightrain : http://www.mediafire.com/?m8nne94l3iabc6c

29. Jam : http://www.mediafire.com/?r3l313ojdb2p0cb

30. Madagascar : http://www.mediafire.com/?3inkj134saf2fr2

31. DF : http://www.mediafire.com/?f8la10cxvfv88c1

32. UTLH : http://www.mediafire.com/?ku2kznv8irkssg9

33. Band jam : http://www.mediafire.com/?ozz16vabiwc375h

34. Patience : http://www.mediafire.com/?dtil9kxn597bapr

35. Solo : http://www.mediafire.com/?rzgb07537u7a5wk

36. PC : http://www.mediafire.com/?q5qno6t0210d847

Not bad. Thanks to Carioca Ausländer.

oh. look. a download LOL

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can't believe people are still arguing over the same things. In every topic.

And as somebody smack in the middle, who has been on both sides, there is no doubt that the worshippers are far more negative than anybody else. Look at bran in those post. I only read a couple pages of the thread, but in every post he has to personally insult the other person. Why can't the worshippers stick to the topic? If somebody says something negative about Axl or the band, attack their statement and show them why they are wrong. Why can't you do that? Instead it is always "you are a coward bitter ex fan who must be miserable in real life." ......."uh, ok. Sure. But back to the topic. Did you see Axl mess up and walk off stage?"........"you e-expert scumbag. Are u retarded? You are just mad because there is no reunion. You must hate your life. Go get laid."........"not sure what that has to do with Axl messing up, but OK. Your thoughts on his mess up?".........and it goes on and in.

Nobody is saying that Axl doesn't have the right to play the songs he helped make famous.

People just want to see the new band be more than a cover and touring band, that is making a living playing other people's music.

If you think about it, the so called "bitter haters" are actually more interested in the current band than the worshippers are. Because we want to hear what they can do. Lots of people can cover popular songs. I am more interested in hearing what the current band can create, rather than hearing them play other people's songs.

The worshippers love to hear DJ and bbf play slash and Izzy songs. I want to hear what DJ and bbf can do on their own. Guess I have more faith in the current band than the worshippers do.

As for last nights show. Haha, some guy in here actually said that ONlY people who attended the show should be able to comment on it? Funny. So some of these overseas shows would have 3 toyal posts. Weird, i thought this was a forum?

Swearing at your drummer and walking off stage.......childish. There is Axl's way. And there is a singer who would have laughed, "holy crap frank can we end this song already".......and the singer who would have remained composed in stage, then discussed it with frank in private. Axl is a jerk, has been since day one, and he even admits it.

So my reaction is "that was funny, typical Axl, what else happened in the show?' It wasn't the end of the world, he has done much worse, they all have probably laughed about it, not worth fans having a battle over it.

The sad or funny thing about this forum? If everybody stopped with the insults, I bet that most if us all actually agree on 90% of what is going on. If people stopped with the personal insults, stopped trying to be topic dictators, stopped carrying grudges, stopped thinking Axl was gonna PM you because you defend him in every post, stopped fighting about a word....classic line up vs original..........wanting new music as opposed to demanding/entitlement......if we stopped all that, I bet this forum would thrive with positive talk. There will always be a couple haters and worshippers, but I bet the remaining 99% of the forum would get along.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



×
×
  • Create New...