JimiRose

All we want/need now is perhaps and Atlas. Ideally soul monster and the general and state of grace too. But EVEN I will be satisfied with 2 new songs in the set.

Whaaat where you see this? I paid £100 for Manchester a couple weeks ago ffs

Richards solo is perfect. Slash is noodling again, dizzy and melissa perfect. Axl... in 2010 he sounded so good on this song. I can't see how he can sing it better tbh, there arent any low baritone bits in this song and theres no extreme screams, it's literally all sung in that range that he has completely lost, which makes it a strange choice. tbh at least its a different song to usual.

They're down for 2 hour 15 on the lineup, though there is a 15 minute leeway, so if they started on time they could get 2 hour 30 in maximum before they're cut.

Percentages. Slash said 5/6 songs. We now know 3 are absurd, hardschool, perhaps. Strongly suspect soul monster and atlas shrugged. That leaves 1 or maybe no other songs worked on. it didnt leak in 2019 and so far all the other 2 soon to be 3 did leak in 2019. It appeared ready for release in 2010 and for whatever reason it's not been mentioned since by anyone in the band. Best I think we can hope for now would be 2028 CD boxset version. Though it is probably the one GnR song I want to hear more than any other.

That could be on the setlist, we only saw one page right? as could soul monster or SoG or the General... haha ok probably not the general, that's dead forever. But who knows what the other pages said

There's at least 3 or 4 that can be swapped out too. Witchita, double talking jive, michelle, nice boys can all probably go and have the 4 new songs that they have recorded waiting to come out...

My michelle

Oh my friend. You really don't understand GnR.

patience coming.

To all those saying this setlist is perfect - no. No new song yet. A new song, then it is the perfect first show.

Now who is telling people how to act and what to enjoy.... you can brown nose GnR but don't be a hypocrite mr SoE!

rich snobs who compare diamond watches only knowing the hits? in Abu Dhabi!? Never!

we know theyre gonna play nightrain nov rain scom dc OR patience and paradise. Prob KOHD too. thats if they dont play coma or locomotive, any new songs or any more covers. Let's all pray that KOHD has been cut.

fuck me this could be a 4 hour show

Spoken style verse of anything goes? I think he's definitely realised what he can and cant sing anymore an how to sing them. That's a good sign.

Dude, it's thursday

Glad they brought down on the farm out, that'll 100% be used at glastonbury. Now give us thyme perhaps atlas and soul monster and this will be their best show since 2016

We'll find out tomorrow

fingers crossed it does mean we are getting both, but I think that's probably a little optimistic given recent history. I want both, but one isn't enough without the other into year 8 of the tour. It was celebrated in 2016 and tolerated in 2017/18. but not now.

Sadly, you are the reason GnR Suck so much. They throw us a crumb and you accept it and say you are not worthy. They then believe we as fans are not worthy and now no longer even offer the crumb, when in reality they should be giving us the whole cake. Thank you SoE and Soul Monster. As you are the main brown nosers of TB and Axl in 2023, I am going to have to hold you both personally responsible for the decline of GnR. I'm sure there are thousands more who suck just as bad, but sadly you're going to have to bear the brunt. GnR are a legacy act (a poor one too) pretending they're a creative force just enough to keep suckers paying those extortionate prices. Or you could wake up and demand new music.

Everyone here cumming their pants at the idea GnR are playing bad obsession and pretty tied up. Pull yourselves together. They will butcher them. We want new music and progression, not a slightly worse version of something we already had. I understand they've given us so little, that even a cup of piss tastes like fresh lemonade after a day stuck in the desert. But it isn't enough if they're not given us a new single at least. Just one!

That rules out America though

I think you have to add in everything else that has been said 'all new show' 'We have no setlist' 'The show is so exciting' 'we have 5/6 new songs recorded, 1 or 2 are going to be released this summer i think' (summer 2022) 'the new album is ready to go in 3-6 months' (the MANAGER of the band in 2019 or 2020?) the constant 'teasing' by slash and duffs partners. They know exactly what they are doing and it wouldn't surprise me if its come from the shitty management. 'We're struggling to sell tickets susan, can you say you've heard a new song and its epic?' Or Meegan 'accidentally' streaming a few seconds of unheard songs in rehearsal etc. its almost as if they have a running bet on how long they can mug off their audience for and get away with it.

I think the term brown nosing was the term earlier used. jarmo has the job already, Axl won't hire you, so better to be honest and call it out rather than defending every terrible thing they do. And I disagree. They do owe me. If i buy a high priced ticket to a show and get the performance we got at the Tottenham hotspur stadium, then i feel short changed. Do I get my money back? If Slash gives an interview that says new music is coming (and fortus et al) and I think yes I want to be at a show where they play that new music, and go, then they do not play any new music, again I am being short changed. You keep describing GnR as a product and transaction. That's fine. I am not happy with the product I am paying for and I am being lied to in order to spend my money on said product. Don't give me 'I should know better than to trust what they say' Or 'Axl has sounded shit for years, you know what you are getting' No - That is not what is being advertised. What they are advertising is an incredible show at high level prices and teasing new music occasionally to keep people hooked. They're not calling it a nostalgia tour, even if that is what it is. Do you honestly think that is defendable? People reserve the right to moan and complain in this scenario because they are not getting value for money. I used to be like you, defend this band to the death. Then I started thinking for myself. It's not too late for you to start calling a spade a spade here SM Edit* You mention you dont see why people moan every week - would their even be a mygnr without fans giving their opinion. whether it be negative or positive? The band do no media, nothing interesting in shows, release no new music. So we have to talk about something!?