TO END ALL GUITAR DEBATE

[Chewbacca]

I really want to hear the current bands version of Oh My God compared to the vid I saw for RIR in 2001.

Yeah, Me too. Bucket, Finck and BBF, BTW.

[Kid A]

A month ago I would have said bucket.

My current answer: Bumble

[Nosaj Thing]

Buckethead all the fuckin' way!

[Georgy Zhukov]

Ron is a close second to me. To me he has more restraint than Buckethead did. Buckethead was a beast on the old songs. He made past members look bad.

[James Bond]

I voted Ron overall. He's an amazing player and he always goes above and beyond for fans. Even though he didn't contribute to the writing of Chinese Democracy, the parts he did definitely added to the songs rather than took away, to me anyways.

In terms of technical talent, I still think it's Ron. Buckethead is in a league of his own as a guitarist and has created some really beautiful, melodic music (Electric Tears comes to mind, as well as Colma) as well as some pure shred, but I think Bumblefoot can "out shred" him, if that makes sense. Not that playing fast is everything, of course. Ron is able to cover all the parts in Guns (Buckethead and Slash), and when you watch those guitar clinic videos where he just wings a song by playing multiple parts and the vocal melody at the same time, it's quite unbelievable. He's extremely good at that kind of stuff.

[batman007]

Better is my fav song, so I love Robin for that. I love Robin s solo on TIL. Bucket though is mindblowing! Live is Ron. Good and hard topic!

[moreblack]

so has all guitar debate ended?

[Georgy Zhukov]

The shredders always seems to win these debates. Chosing between Buckethead and Bumblefoot is hard.

As for the rest Fortus probably puts them to shame.

[CivilWar07]

Bumble for me followed by 4tus.

Fuckin love the both of them

[ThinkAboutYou]

I put Buckethead and DJ Ashba. Buckethead for his CD recordings and specially for nuKOHD and DJ for being the best thing that has ever happened to nuGnR.

How is he the best thing to ever happen to nuGNR when we haven't heard a GNR song by him? Are you basing it off his sixx am or Motley Crue work?