What was the best NewGNR lineup?

[Freddie Mercury's Ghost]

What was the best touring lineup of NewGNR?

Gonna go with:

Axl/Tommy/Dizzy/Pitman/Fortus/Robin/Bumblefoot/Brain (May 2006-June 2006)

Brain was on fire before he left. The Rock am Ring performance was ace.

[Cosmo]

It's SOOO fuckin hard to choose!!!!! No line-up has even come close to the charisma and friendly chemistry this band has but.... Robin and Bucket are awesome!!! I say:

- Best technical and possibly songwriting line-up: '02

- Most charismatic, best stage presence line-up: This one.

- Most tight line-up, with perfect shows: '06.

I just can't choose. I Axl counts, it's definitely '06 though.

[F*ck Fear]

I like what Robin and Bucket did on the album, but since seeing NewGNR four times (02,06,10,11) I have to say my favorite line up is the current one. The live shows are fucking fantastic. They're a fucking band.

[Tyler Drama]

best post slash lineup? ultimate post slash lineup? how do we decide between best and ultimate? what are the differences between the two threads?

In the ultimate thread you have the opportunity to pick line-ups that have never existed.

By the way, two of the line-ups in the poll are exactly the same.

[The Archer]

I miss the '06 line up but I'm happy to go with this one.

[Black Roses]

Hi, i'm a new member .

I think 2002 is the best. But Axl sounded like shit in 2002 .

[Cosmo]

Hi, i'm a new member .

I think 2002 is the best. But Axl sounded like shit in 2002 .

Hi man! Welcome! He sure did haha

[Silent Jay]

another useless thread

[bacardimayne]

Axl/Tommy/Dizzy/Pitman/Fortus/DJ Ashba/Bumblefoot/Frank (December 2009-present) (8 votes [47.06%])

[finck6]

I like what Robin and Bucket did on the album, but since seeing NewGNR four times (02,06,10,11) I have to say my favorite line up is the current one. The live shows are fucking fantastic. They're a fucking band.

robin and bucket did on the chinese democracy record what slash did on appetite, lies, and illusions records

[Bruno P.]

The 06 one would be my first choice, but the current gives us a better show imo - they played for the longest time together, didn't have any tours canceled, got to play some of the best older songs and fans favorites, etc. I certainly like Finck better than DJ and Brain better than Frank, though.

[finck6]

The 06 one would be my first choice, but the current gives us a better show imo - they played for the longest time together, didn't have any tours canceled, got to play some of the best older songs and fans favorites, etc. I certainly like Finck better than DJ and Brain better than Frank, though.

i prefer robin and brain over DJ and Frank too

[Guest Gunns]

02 lineup for bucket and finck

Edited June 8, 2012 by Gunns

[finck6]

02 lineup for bucket and finck

02 lineup with bucket and finck does it for me too

[A.J.]

02 lineup for me as well. Robin and Brain are a must, imho. And for Buckethead vs Star Trooper Head ... erm ... Bumblefoot ... ... I simply don't like Ron's guitar sound. On most songs, it just doesn't fit, it just doesn't feel right. Plus his shredding seems too randomized at times. On the other hand, Ron brought back Don't Cry, so it really was a close call between 02 and 06.

Edited June 8, 2012 by A.J.