Layla VS. Another Brick In The Wall Part 2

[Black Sabbath]

Out of these two pre-November Rain jams, which do you prefer? I liked Another Brick In The Wall, but I love the Layla jam, honestly. Hope they continue with that for awhile.

[Crash Diet]

layla is too cheesy for me

[Lio]

Difficult choice, I like them both, and I really like how Axl sings Another Brick in the Wall. But I went for Layla anyway, because there's more piano in it. That's why I love the old intros even better, It's Alright, Everything, Dust in the Wind, where he sings and plays the piano.

[Silent Jay]

I like this one, with Pitman's weird voices.

But BBF truly shines on Layla.

[Zint]

Layla

[Bruno P.]

Layla

[November_rain]

Both are cool but I prefer Layla.

[Powerage5]

Layla

[Thin White Duke]

Layla, but I am very biased because of the originals.

[MrSoftie]

Layla is beautiful.

[Val22]

Layla is such a beautiful song. Love Axl playing piano.

Layla is such a more powerful song and knowing the reason behind this song makes it all the more passionate in my eyes.

Eric Clapton at his best both singing and playing his guitar.

Wish I could have heard this song live instead of another brick in the wall.

[WFA]

Layla

[DR DOOM]

Not to be a dick, but neither?

If you're not Roger Waters or David Gilmour, odds are overwhelming you shouldn't be singing a Pink Floyd song, even if you're Axl Rose.

Wouldn't it be cool if they jammed a Guns N Roses song, like a UYI medley or something?

[robin2002]

Not to be a dick, but neither?

If you're not Roger Waters or David Gilmour, odds are overwhelming you shouldn't be singing a Pink Floyd song, even if you're Axl Rose.

Wouldn't it be cool if they jammed a Guns N Roses song, like a UYI medley or something?

^ This.

I know it's quiet and not much to talk about in GNR world, but I really do get fed up reading 'Which cover should GN'R do next' or which cover they do better live etc - I'd much rather hear more GN'R stuff than another AC/DC cover or whatever.

...'another brick in the wall' for me, but anyway, as you were.

Edited June 30, 2014 by robin2002

[spliff]

layla but he should bring back it's alright