jimisbatman

What I'd love more than a new album is a boxset of CD including the early album versions.

Always liked OMG, definitely rivals anything on CD in my opinion.   Cant help think that other CD songs (irs, if the world, sorry) were made with a harder edge in mind like OMG, however were changed due to the musical landscape changing.  

Hi team, cant seem to find the post which describes the differences between the different versions of CD album, MSL & anti-quiet.   And the post about what versions has buckethead on. Any directions to the old postings would be much appreciated 

Definitely prefer CDll over the reunion given we won't get any new music from current line up anytime soon. 

1 hour ago, Lio said:

Ready for the January announcement now

I believe

Who said announcement will be in January? 

Although I don't care for a live album, if the album included studio versions of CD + Better with the new intros and one new song it would be cool.

20 hours ago, marinergtfc said:

...I’m fucking basing my fucking statement on fucking rumours.

badda-bing badda-bong.

😏

Duff's wife recently hashtagged doublealbum live.  IMO, This sucks, a live album is only good for new better intro, nothing else.

Has any of the 2001 CD version leaked?

We need some more leaks so we can piece together our own CDII.

I always wondered why people hated on OMG and couldn't understand why.  IMO the vocals are very melodic and the industrial sound was a welcomed departure from the classic sound. 

My CD era go to songs are: OMG, TWAT (cd version), Maddy (MSL - due to the clearness of the multiple guitar parts simultaneously), Shacklers, Prostitute and Riad (antiquiet versions), Better (cd version with new live beginning sliced in).

I love this remix, definitely my favourite so far.

1 hour ago, Powerage5 said:

The 1999 version doesn't. Here's a breakdown:

TWAT 1999 - no Bucket
TWAT 2001 - no Bucket
TWAT demo 2006 leak, 6:03 version - shortened Bucket solo
TWAT demo 2006 leak, 6:43 version - full Bucket solo
TWAT 2007 leak - full Bucket solo
TWAT 2008 leak - full Bucket solo
TWAT album version - full Bucket solo

 

I realize it gets confusing - we commonly refer to 99/01 tracks with the year tacked on the end, but then you have like, the 2006 demos for example that are probably from some time before that year. If I had to guess the 2006 leaks are probably from somewhere around 2003, but I can't say for sure. 2007 and 2008 leaks are probably from about when they leaked, considering how much closer they got to the album version, and that when the song was played live in 2006 it didn't yet have the weird sound effects over the choir intro. 

Thanks powerage5, useful info.  When did bucket join and leave? and how do we know what demo's he played on?

On 28/06/2018 at 2:52 PM, Amir said:

And don't get me started on any version of TWAT that doesn't have the Bucket solo...

This is an amateur question, however, what versions if TWAT have buckethead on them apart from 1999 version? 

2 hours ago, zombux said:

reportedly sometime right after BBF joined the band in May 2006, he received older demo tracks to lay his guitar over them. so the left channel is probably mid-2006, the right channel unknown, probably from Buckethead era.

Thanks.  Just trying to put together my era specific CD mix.  

Is there any consensus re: time period of silkworms/OMG leaks?   

15 hours ago, Estrangedfx said:

Seriously???? Oh. My. God. WTF is going on??? Haha. This is..... Awesome!!! So many leaks. Literally... It keeps happening!!! A joyous day/week to be a GNR fan, indeed. 

What has leaked since Madagascar? 

12 hours ago, Wagszilla said:

Kaneda 👏🏻

You hoarder dudes should send me Silkworms and Oh My God. 

I’m a nice fella that’s why 

 

I'd pay some serious money to get my hands on Oh My God.

17 hours ago, saint_seiya said:

axis vocals sound new??!!

I was going to question if the vocals and music is new or original takes?  And when they were rumoured to be in the studio, was that for AFD as opposed new stuff?

17 hours ago, estrangedtwat said:

Ain't Going Down is the instrumental version.  Wonder if they're saving the one with vocals for later?

I was looking forward to the vocal version.

46 minutes ago, comboguns said:

now is very important to us fans, to make positive coments, to help GNR feel more motivated, imagine they release more box sets, new album, a box set with 20 live cds... etc

Or a Chinese Democracy box set, virtual fist pump lol

Love Adler's drumming, so funky. 

This has probably been discussed before, but are there any UYI demos with Adler floating around the internet? 

Better than "the 2017 big 3" lol

Personally, I'm a bigger gnr fan than Oasis fan, and it's hard to rate music as it's subjective.  However, it's hard to deny the fact that Neol has single-handedly written alot of great singles, and IMO, probably even more so than Gnr.  And, no, I will not see Oasis if they reformed but quite happily travelled around the world to see Gnr many times. 

Awesome,  CDll, cant wait

On 13/11/2017 at 9:05 AM, zombux said:

to correct you - in the last 9 years (that is, since ChiDem was released), we only got one song (Going Down), a few remixes and this one old mix. 

What remixes did we get other than DJ's better?