Vince Neil vs Axl Rose

[Powerage5]

Motley Crue is a shit band, there I said it. Put Van Halen and Kiss into a blender and you get Motley Crue, not as good as either. They are one of the most overrated bands in the history of rock. Nikki Sixx and Tommy Lee are the only ones in that band with any decent talent. Motley helped rush in the "hair band" era of rock. The era that Guns n' Roses helped destroy a few years later. Fuck Motley!!!

For the record, has Vince ever even wrote a song worth a damn? I'm pretty sure Nikki wrote all their "hits".

Please Mick has more talent in one finger than Tommy, Nikki, and Vince combined.

[Iron MikeyJ]

Maybe Mick was more talented, but where does he rank among great guitarists from his era???? Nowhere near the top, doesn't help your argument much.

[Use Your Delusion 1]

wtf? One is a rock icon, the other is a pop metal joke

[liers]

Keep in mind, you're asking this on a GnR forum. We might be biased....

Aside from Home Sweet Home, I can't stand Vince Neil. His voice is too high pitched. I like axl's mickey mouse voice better than.

[RussTCB]

Just listened to the Greatest Hits LP for the first time in a while. My GOD what a bad ass rock song this is: