If you could choose ONE single Ex-GnR member to substitute a current one, which one would it be?

[Cosmo]

As the title says, if you could pick one single ex-member from any GnR line-up to come back and join this current formation (replacing the equivalent current member), which one would it be?

[ssiscool]

Izzy. Purely for the songwirtting skills

[The Glow Inc.]

Buckethead, but I'd replace Ashba.

It CLEARLY wouldn't be Guns n' Roses but Fortus + Buckethead + Bumblefoot in the same band ? Where do I sign ?

[Cosmo]

I'd choose Izzy too, luckily it would end up in a new You Could Be Mine....

[Powerage5]

Izzy. Not that I dislike Fortus, but Izzy is my favorite former member.

[Cosmo]

Nice to see so much Izzy lovin'...

[Kill Devil Hill]

Izzy. I still miss the guy.

[YOUCOULDBEMINE.]

Paul, but he isn't an option so I'd bring back Izzy

[Cosmo]

Paul, but he isn't an option so I'd bring back Izzy

Paul? Really? Well, I guess he DOES have songwriting chemistry with Axl at least...

[Use Your Delusion 1]

Izzy, closely followed by Slash and Duff

[Chewbacca]

Robin.

[James Bond]

Izzy would be great for songwriting, but I voted Duff. I really love the chemistry between Fortus, Ashba, and Ron so I would hate to see one of them go in favor of bringing Izzy back to the live fold. Izzy probably wouldn't want to tour big places anyways. Duff to me is a realistic choice, and as much as I like Tommy, I'd see him go before one of the guitarists.

Slash is the reason I play guitar, but at the moment I'm happier with him doing his solo stuff with Myles. Overall, we really got some great music from multiple projects after the split up.

[batman007]

I like Frank, he has really.grown on me. I really miss Brain though.

Edited October 18, 2011 by batman007