JimiRose

Ah used to lover her, completely forgot about that. Agree a theatre tour would be best. 2k max capacity, intimate rock show.

Taylor swift also does 44 song setlists https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/taylor-swift/2024/melbourne-cricket-ground-melbourne-australia-33ad9425.html I thought that might be the one thing GnR was better at. Turns out she's got us covered there too

I actually think we will get this in the next 5 years or so. Maybe a one off show, or a small tour in theatres or arenas. The only thing is it has to be just these on 5. No dizzy, no piano no 3rd guitarist etc. Give us 85-90 So I've tried to only pick songs from that era that steven would have a part in either demo, live or studio. Setlist Welcome to the Jungle It's So Easy Mr Brownstone Reckless Life Shadow Of Your Love Rocket Queen Out Ta Get Me Civil War Rocket Queen You're Crazy (Lies Version) My Michelle Think About You Nice Boys Anything Goes You Could Be Mine Slash Solo Sweet Child O' Mine KOHD Nightrain Encore 20. Patience 21. Don't Cry 22. Paradise City I left out a Duff or Izzy solo spot. I don't recall there being many in those early days, but if Axl wanted it broken up then I wouldn't mind seeing DTJ, Dust and Bones or 14 years added, or a duff punk cover. I also think there's room for Whole Lotta Rosie which that line up did (as well as others since) or heartbreak hotel, that would match the energy of that era, but whether 67 year old does it justice I dont know.

I like that change, its melancholy as a whole, it means the song starts positive in a sad way, then gets quite down, then picks up again from the solo to the outro which actually seems quite hopeful. Compared to absurd, perhaps, the general, it actually seems like a fully fledged song, the instruments build, the drums are different in each section, not looped, the guitar lowers and reaches crescendos and axl clearly recorded each bit individually, not just do the chorus once and then just say, thatll do 3 times. Effort went into this song to be an actual song

There's been nothing to talk about here since CD2 didnt come out in 2010, never been a sniff of a full album release since

Where are these rumours

Nice work, gnr should release it and just say its them. Wouldn't put it past fernando

Unless GnR have a smash hit single that is literally everywhere and followed that with a big album release with Axl and slash doing interviews and being in the public conscious, then they will never be relevant enough for this. in the current social zietgiest GnR are just some old guys that don't do much accept tour the hits with a singer that can't sing that well anymore. No modern rock bands are relevant. they're all heritage. GnR are as heritage as Kiss. RHCP are more relevant - they release music and get out there individually and they wouldn't get the gig either. I don't think GnR have that single or willing to release and promote the hell out of it. I think Monsters and Atlas Shrugged are great songs and both would get a few weeks rock radio rotation, but they're not going to be smash hits, so forget about it.

Fair enough - the vocals won't change!

History tells us it will sound exactly the same in 2024 as 1999.

https://planetradio.co.uk/planet-rock/news/rock-news/jon-bon-jovi-voice/?fbclid=IwAR0G7F-SljTE7_j0QOMLsPWGqerLfPiNtXOEN3lrv7IJ3z-Fod_yGHrO7HQ Do we think Axl would ever come out and say this. JBJ has admitted he couldn't sing anymore and also the reason for it, he's now had this drastic surgery to try to get back to his best and if it doesnt work, he won't fleece the fans with him not being able to sing. Should Axl try something similar ps. please no one jump in and say Axls voice is fine he sounds great blah blah, it's shot to pieces unless singing baritone. obv age plays a part but if he could get back to 2010 levels that would be incredible, so hopefully he does acknowledge the issue and then try to fix it, especially with GnR talking at least 12-18 months off. what better time? Jon Bon Jovi addresses vocal issues and vows not to tour unless he sounds 'great' "If I can't be great, I'm out"

I'm a Demi God so you will worship me and respect your higher rankers

Atlas and Monsters official release. Seven and Quick song with proper vocal leak. We get that and there's nothing else better than any of those that we don't know about, then time to bury the CD era.

Just stop digging, you are destroying yourself The fact you have compared her to them just shows the ignorance levels we have to deal with here. Next you'll be comparing the rolling stones and limp bizkit

People here will have you believe she's been around 5 minutes and in a couple of years she'll be forgotten again. Like she hasn't been the top artist in the world for 15 years and is bigger every year on top of that. People will choose the stats that suit them or always say 'well back in my day blah blah' but pretty sure every single meaningful record in music is now taylor swifts and shes barely in her early 30s. but some 53 year old 80s rock fan doesn't watch any news, any contemporary music or any sport, and doesnt know who she is, therefore she can't be as big as madonna was. HA.

It's cool, ignorance is bliss. It's weird that people volunteer such ignorance. 'I dont know them or like them therefore they can't be that big' LOL

You mean like ACDCs.... anyone can say something similar about rocks fav bands. Her early country stuff isn't actually that bad, if you like country rock. her newer stuff is for kids and young women mainly of course, but it's not all made on a computer like dance music or on a laptop on some tiktok. The ignorance of people here... unbelievable. Maybe they have lived in a box since 2008

Taylor swift is the biggest artist in the world, and has been around since 2008. That's 16 years into her career. not some fly by night. she has sold out wembley stadium for SIX NIGHTS this summer, with millions of people not getting tickets. This is perhaps the most ignorant thing ever said on this forum. She is bigger than GnR could have ever dreamed and will be bigger than GnR still in 10 years. I'm not even a fan of hers, but the absolute BS in this comment needs calling out. Now, you can say 'I dont rate her, i dont think she's good etc' but you cannot say something as ridiculous as above. I'm sure there were grandads like you in 1965 saying the same thing about the beatles, yet here we are 60 years later. She also writes every single one of her songs and can play guitar and piano. So no she's not plastic, you just dont like her music. and thats fine.

Taylor swift just announced a new album due out in TWO months, that she's been making for the past 2 years, whilst touring the world and re recording her old albums. ARE YOU WATCHING AXL ROSE? It really isn't hard.

I think hardschool, perhaps, monsters and atlas shrugged would have all been very radio friendly, compared to CD which really only had better as an obvious radio track. Going down would have definitely been successful. there was obviously 4/5 more songs that were going to go on the album and as we haven't heard them we can't speculate that it would have been a bad album. if they were equal quality to those 7 you have listed, then it probably would have been on par with CD. plus, if released as an album it would have been mixed like CD and consistent. the versions we have all sound like they are mixed by different people in different studios on different platforms. but realistically in 2010 they would have been mixed and mastered together and had a much more cohesive natural flowing album.

The famous punk as fuck bassist and song writer for two pound tea. That ain't no secret !

Had this response from the creative works guys - what easter eggs do you think they are referring to? Jimi Chialoufas Was the video initially supposed to be The General and Monsters combined? Hence the constant reference to monsters in the vid and original artwork? 34m Like Reply Author Creative Works London Jimi Chialoufas nope, nothing to do with each other, Monsters tend to appear in children's Nightmares , that's why there are some in there. There's absolutely no hidden references or anything to any other track. 25m Like Reply Active Jimi Chialoufas Creative Works Londonfair enough, thanks for getting back to me 17m Like Reply Author Creative Works London Jimi Chialoufas there's a few other Easter eggs in there , see if you can find them

Creative works said it wasn't Axl's handwriting but it sure looks similar.

Agree on all points. Soul Monster is such a better title. best song they've got in the locker and they've completely fucked it up. get it out now

GnR night 2 London 2010 O2 Arena, the return of duff. Band on fire, Axl sounded best he's ever sounded. great setlist. MDMA and got with 3 different chicks in the crowd that night. Never happened before and never since. God bless that night