-
Posts
3,570 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
22
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Store
Events
Everything posted by Voodoochild
-
Tommy Stinson on Chinese, GNR and Axl
Voodoochild replied to Dean's topic in GUNS N' ROSES - DISCUSSION & NEWS
I like Fortus, but he was butt-hurt because he would play all the Bucket stuff in 2006. I think he would do a great job in IRS and TWAT, but I really dislike what he tries to play in Better currently. As far as I know, the soundboard guys had to kinda work it out to add the third guitar player (Bumble) at the last minute, as they were preparing the tour for quite some time before for just Robin and Richard. That's why Bumble was really fucked up in the mix for the first NY shows and the European leg of the 2006 tour. It all started to get better in the UK tour and def in those US dates. -
Tommy Stinson on Chinese, GNR and Axl
Voodoochild replied to Dean's topic in GUNS N' ROSES - DISCUSSION & NEWS
No serious journalist would ever submit questions for a pre-interview, it's offensive to actually suggest that (and trust me, that happens a lot). At best, you can say what general topics you want to cover, but that's it. IMO, it's just not the focus of the interviewer nor the interviewed. If CD was the central subject, then yeah, they should def have more in depth questions. Never heard about that, but I doubt it. From the soundboards and videos I watched from 2002, I never saw any evidence of anything like it. Also they used in-ear monitors, they all have their own mixes there. -
Tommy Stinson on Chinese, GNR and Axl
Voodoochild replied to Dean's topic in GUNS N' ROSES - DISCUSSION & NEWS
Well, they at least had a version of the record that could have been released in 2000/01, after Bucket's additions. Before that, I agree that the record lacked a bit of guitar work, but the vocals were almost there for 90% of the songs. -
Freedom of speech does not equal to shit on other people's living room. Yeah, you're "free" to do it, but should you? Wouldn't that have consequences? Funny thing is that freedom of speech is often justification for absurdity, but not for fair criticism or to label things properly as lies.
-
Well, I was a journalist for 20 years and I can say that people often chose the picture by what they think it will generate more clicks. Every single story about Axl has this "look how decadent he is" angle for this reason too. Also, people from the Entertainment section tends to be more inclined to the alternative and trendy stuff. Axl was always viewed as an easy target for them, especially since he refuses to actually give interviews in the last 30 years.
-
LOL at "foreign country". It's all assumptions. Nobody had mention Hard Skool either, yet the song existed. Why would any of those people mention an unreleased song? I understand the concept of an idea, but you're making up a whole story to back it up your assumption. The facts: we have this PRL instrumental from the 1999/2000 sessions. Axl mentioned the song in 2001 as the title-track for a follow up album. To me sounds reasonable that the song would be more than just an idea by then. But I don't know, I was just asking.
-
Lol, who's grasping at straws? I didn't see it was for GNR, I was just presenting the possibility and even said it was very unlikely. I believe it could may be for GNR and I don't think this means much as the problem wasn't just recording, but releasing it. And we dont know if Axl wasn't in London already, but a 2-hours flight from Germany is really not a big deal, not sure why would this be so eventful either. Hahaha that was tongue in cheek, but he was indeed inspired in the tour. Maybe he likes Europe more. BTW, the title of the thread is just fine in my opinion. If/when is confirmed that Axl was there to record for a guest spot, then it will be updated. Not sure why people overreacted to this. I know. Maybe the guy wanted to actually be there instead of letting some assistant to do it. Who knows.
-
But he could also record this track for Schenker in LA. And he could also have recorded anything with Voss in Germany before. Maybe Axl needed in London because thats where/when his "muse" appeared. Also, wasn't Axl in France? I'm not saying this is for a GNR song for sure, I'm just pointing that it's still a possibility, albeit unlikely for the time being. It's not unheard (pun intended) for Axl. He did the same thing with Sebastian Bach.
-
I disagree. I think it was professionally mixed indeed, but there's a lot of the punchy-ness that was present on the demos and were absent on the album. It lacks not only a more clear bass, but also the attack that the songs suggest. While I like some of Bumble additions, his rhythm guitars are way too loud in the mix and often changed too much of the original arrangement. The worst was in Street of Dreams and Riad, where his guitar (right channel) pushed away to be condensed in the left channel the others (Richard/Paul and Robin) guitars. Even some of the cool synths from the 2001/02 era were missing in the final version - not because it was edited out, but because it was so low in the mix that you can barely hear it or only noticeable on the stems. I've seen this theory. Not impossible, but very unlikely that the deal is what it's preventing anything. I mean, they did release stuff lately, so it's not like they can't do anything.