who, based on their previous track record, shows more potential in writing some big guns on the next(next) album, Dj or Ron?

[Guest Gunns]

who do you think shows the most premise in writing the'big guns' based solely on their previous work outside of GnR.

Ron or Dj?

Edited May 11, 2013 by Gunns

[vaida]

without Buckethead or Robin, any future Axl album's won't match Chinese.. To be fair, the only thing interesting about Chinese was Buckethead and Robin..

[Towelie]

Ron.

[bacardimayne]

DJ's more likely to write something that Adler fans would enjoy. Ron's more likely to write a good song.

[Towelie]

without Buckethead or Robin, any future Axl album's won't match Chinese.. To be fair, the only thing interesting about Chinese was Buckethead and Robin..

Yes, because Robin Finck and Bucketheads collective songwriting efforts far surpass dross like November Rain, Estranged, Breakdown, Dead Horse, TIL and other terrible songs solely penned by Axl.

Idiot.

Edited May 11, 2013 by Towelie

[wasted]

Dj Ashba.

[Crash Diet]

who do you think shows the most premise in writing the'big guns' based solely on their previous work outside of GnR.

Ron or Dj?

Ron, but i hope 4tus got a chance to shine

[ThinkAboutYou]

Ron for sure

[James Bond]

Big guns? Ron.

A massive hit? DJ.

[SoulMonster]

Not impressed by any of them, but at least Bumblefoot can make something not dripping of cliché.

[Nosaj Thing]

Not impressed by any of them, but at least Bumblefoot can make something not dripping of cliché.

Yup.

[pe_teko]

izzy

:-)

GnR sucks with Ashba and bumble

Finck was talented.

[- antem]

Big guns? Ron.

A massive hit? DJ.

[niceguy]

The poll is flawed.

It's like asking, "What would you rather have on your pizza? Dog shit or rat shit?"

[sweetness]

Not impressed by any of them, but at least Bumblefoot can make something not dripping of cliché.

This

[gnfnrs1972]

izzy

:-)

GnR sucks with Ashba and bumble

Finck was talented.

If I had a million dollars for every album sold because of finck I'd still be broke as hell.

[Bulldog]

Sadly I think DJ even though Ron is the far superior musician

[wasted]

Cant remember the last time a rock band had a real hit.

[EvH]

Honestly ? Neither.

[luciusfunk]

Big guns? Ron.

A massive hit? DJ.

Ooh good one. This is my answer.

It's funny. Everyone hated Finck when he was in the band. Now he's gone everyone wants him back. I'll bet the same thing happens if DJ leaves.

That being said, I've always liked Finck and I too would like him back, but I don't hate DJ.

[GivenToFly]

I liked the jams Ron had with Richard at the shows I went to in 2012. Something good could come out of their collaboration.

[gnfnrs1972]

Cant remember the last time a rock band had a real hit.

fall out boy, my songs know what you did in the dark. Ha ha haha

[maynard]

Ron doesn't write music. He masturbates his guitar for a living. No chance.

DJ is like a Slash wannabe so he can write catchy stuff, maybe he could write something with a chorus, which were absent in CD.

The thing is. if they were good, Axl would've chosen them before Robin and Bucket. They are 3rd option for some reason...

There won't be a new record in the next 10 years probably, so, DJ and Ron can be out of the band by the time we finally get a new album, with 4th or 5th options.

[The Glow Inc.]

The thing is. if they were good, Axl would've chosen them before Robin and Bucket. They are 3rd option for some reason...

Not saying DJ is a great songwriter but Axl did ask him to join back in 2000 and he declined...

[Bruno P.]

Buckethead is a second rate musician. He was asked to join because DJ refused to join Axl's band. He's a replacement.