ZoSoRose

I’m hoping the transition I’m from Robin to Slash is better with the higher quality release. Might just sound worse with this recording but who knows

Sounds a lot more like its original demo than either Absurd or Hard Skool do. Like those, it could have used another vocal part or something but it’s still cool. That chorus is really classic Axl. It’s a shame it’ll be playback live Slash’s solo sounds alright. Interesting they kept a bit of Robin

Yes, the beginning bend

I can’t believe this Looking forward to hearing this and hopefully The General in a month or so

=(

We have been making breadcrumbs out of shit since Chinese came out. Shitcrumbs, if you will

Ross is everywhere in rock

Why do people think it’s not coming now? This follows the exact same release pattern as Absurd. Why wouldn’t it be Perhaps now and The General in the fall?

It wasn’t an outright travesty like Rise of Skywalker, at least

I’ve always heard near the man but apparently that’s wrong

Just give me all the leftovers and put me out of my misery. Or actually, maybe it would be good to make it to 100 and still wonder about these god damn songs on here every week

That’s so lame in my opinion. The chorus Is best part of the song. I get using playback for backing vocals sometimes (still lamer than divying up with band members), but that part is the main vocal line

This Is the real grail for me, Perhaps is just a means to get there

Ones they have done or rehearsed that I haven’t gotten- Hard Skool Shadow of Your Love Reckless Life There Was a Time Locomotive Catcher in the Rye Anything Goes Dead Horse Bad Obsession Pretty Tied Up Ones they haven’t dug out with this lineup- Right Next Door to Hell Think About You Don’t Damn Me Back off Bitch The General (or any other “new” song) The Garden Garden of Eden Perfect Crime

I’m jumping the gun but I really want a physical single of Perhaps on one side and The General on the other

Hope they keep Hard Skool in the set so I can hear it live in Boston. Would be happy to have Perhaps instead of Absurd

Yay

I remember that

Same! Got OTGM twice in 2016 (heard Slash do it in 2012) and FINALLY got My Michelle in 2017. To date, that’s the only time I have seen a GNR member play it (pretty sure even Adler skipped it when I saw him in 2018)

Big Godzilla fan. Super excited for Minus 1. Loved Shin

Robin gets to record with NIN, tour, RNR HoF, Grammy performance, etc It was definitely smart to leave GnR in 2008 even though we suffered Ashba

Robin’s the shit. Wish it was him in the 2009-2014 lineup, but leaving ended up being a good move for him

Ufo

Who?

It really was a magic show. He had 2 Orange half stacks in stereo. Glorious