You get to replace one member of Guns n' Roses

[username]

Congratulations!

You've won some sort of odd contest, and here's your prize: You get to replace one member of Guns n' Roses with someone else.

There are rules though:

- You can't choose NOT to replace anybody. A choice has to be made.

- You can't replace them for someone who has been in Guns n' Roses before.

Explain who and why.

Edited February 19, 2013 by username

[trqster]

Couldn't you just get rid of a current member or two? One of the reasons NuGn'R is a bit of a parody is that there's just way too many people playing...

[The Glow Inc.]

I'd replace DJ Ashba with Philip Sayce because he can play some mean blues rock.

I was tempted to say BBF just to get him out of here so he can focus on making music...

[AndreCC]

Frank! He's drumming sucks! Hate it when he butchers Mr.Brownstone...

[Crash Diet]

DJ Ashba to any street kid or random guitarist on youtube who has got skills...

Btw anybody who vote for Axl can go fuck themselves....

Yes, his voice is weaker now, but he is the only member in the band now that made GNR's legacy

[Cosmo]

Btw anybody who vote for Axl can go fuck themselves.... Yes, his voice is weaker now, but he is the only member in the band now that made GNR's legacy

He's also the one keeping us from getting new music so I was tempted but....

I'm gonna vote Tommy on this one. First of all, very subpar stage presence. Second, doesn't care if he doesn't release any new material, it appears. Third, his bass lines on CD are really mediocre. Last of all, he only co-wrote two songs. One of them was the single worst track in CD by far, the other is a piano ballad in which he shares songwriting credits with Dizzy and Axl. Don't think he played a major part in it.

[Anonymity]

If replacing with another musician, Frank with Brain.

- i just like Brain better

If just release someone, then Chris.

- dizzy can manage things by himself

Edited February 19, 2013 by Anonymity

[Matthias]

If replacing with another musician, Frank with Brain.

- i just like Brain better

- You can't replace them for someone who has been in Guns n' Roses before.

Edited February 19, 2013 by Matthias

[Rovim]

Voted DJ. I just don't think he's good enough of a guitar player to be in Guns. Bumble and Fortus are on another level imo.

His personality is very off putting to me as well. Like there is nothing genuine about him at all.

I do like Ballad Of Death, and I think he does seem to know his way around a melody, so I'm willing to give him a chance and see what he can do in the studio, but if it was up to me, he'd be gone by now. Frank is a close second. Just not into his drumming style. Not good enough as well imo. To go from Brain to Frank....ouch.

Edited February 19, 2013 by Rovim

[Mindray11]

ashba and that lazy lead singer

[alfierose]

Frank with Meg White. Could make things interesting.

[DieselDaisy]

Couldn't you just get rid of a current member or two? One of the reasons NuGn'R is a bit of a parody is that there's just way too many people playing...

This. They need a cull. I would ditch Ashba, Pitman and Reed and turn the band into a five-piece again.

[Coma16]

Tommy for Beta

[LuanVictor]

Ashba.

[Guest bellastar2355]

Tommy for Beta

I thought she was going to replace him eventually

Fernando and vanessa were going to be in the band along with dijon

[drtydane]

Axl. With myself. At least I wouldn't fuck up the lyrics.

[jekylhyde]

Dizzy... Clone Pittman if you absolutely need a 13th band member.

[James Bond]

Definitely DJ. Let Fortus and Bumble do all the leads and hire someone else for rhythm.

[Ragnar]

Definitely DJ. Let Fortus and Bumble do all the leads and hire someone else for rhythm.

This, drop Ashba Ron and Richard can handle guitars just fine I would kick Pitman out too he`s just useless

Edited February 19, 2013 by Dark Knight