Paradise City. Top 10 of All Time or No?

[Ace Nova]

Discuss.

[IncitingChaos]

No, I do put Novemver Rain and Estranged in my top 10, but Paradise City doesn't do anything special musically. It's a fun song in my opinion, great to listen to, but not really a song that does anything great. It's just fun to have on a playlist.

Obviously that's just my opinion, how we judge and perceive songs is completely different from one another. So someone else's top 10 list might not have the same criteria that mine will. It's all subjective.

[Ace Nova]

This forum has been (apparently) invaded by a bunch of Ashba huggers.

Edited December 25, 2014 by Kasanova King

[downzy]

I'd say it's in my top 10 driving/cruising songs. Love blaring this from my car with the top down

[ThomasZZ]

no, but SCOM can be...

[Johnny Drama]

Top 10 favourite songs to play on guitar for sure.

[bran]

its not even a top 10 gnr song.

[Snowmass]

Merry Xmas to all. I voted yes but I guess it's more due to what the song represents to me....more of a time. And in that time it was awesome......looking at a broader spectrum- is it a top 5 song let alone top 5 Guns song?- I change my vote to a no. Still a kick ass song though.....wish Axl would put it back in main set like the old days.

[Jwalker19]

It's not even in my top-10 GN'R songs.

[netcat]

or No

[Streetchild]

It's a cool song, but not a top 10 of all time.

Not even a top 10 GNR song for me.

[RandallFlagg]

It may make my GNR top ten but nowhere near my all time, Estranged makes it though.

[smoking guns]

It is the ultimate GNR rocker, show closer.

[EvH]

It's a great singalong song. But it's not in my Gn'R top ten, and certainly not in my all time top ten (not that I've ever thought about making one).

[Strange Broue]

Nope


My all time top 10 is always various but if i choose a GNR song in it then it would be YCBM or Locomotive

To be honest: PC is not on my top 10 GNR songs list either

[Kater]

Voted yes, but it would be more like in Top 20.

You could be mine would make into Top 5.

[Nosaj Thing]

Voted no. Great song, definitely one of Gn'R best! But not Top 10 of all time.

[BrayWyatt]

I voted yes, it is my mobile phone ringtone

[EvH]

It is the ultimate GNR rocker, show closer.

I think that You Could Be Mine would've worked better as a show closer. Now that I think of it, awesome opener too, probably.

Edited December 25, 2014 by EvH

[bacardimayne]

Top 10 what?

Songs? No.

Rock songs? No.

GNR songs? No.

GNR songs starting with P? No.

Songs on AFD? No.

Songs that have ever been used to close a GNR show? No.

[Jakey Styley]

Absolutely not, the studio version of this song kinda sucks really. I could maybe go with top 10 live songs.

[DannyVinyard]

Absolutely not, the studio version of this song kinda sucks really. I could maybe go with top 10 live songs.

You may want to get your hearing checked. Studio version is perfection.

For me, this song is definitely in my top 10 of all time, along with November Rain, Estranged, and Sweet Child O' Mine.

[Free Bird]

Well, it's in my top ten from AFD

[dando]

It's a good track but it's not going to make my top 10

[maynard]

It's a fun rock song.