Jump to content
RussTCB

CD Leaks Discussion Thread **NO LINKS, NO ASKING / HINTING FOR LEAKS**

Recommended Posts

honestly, it doesn't sound like Axl at all... and that's the first time i'd hear him "mumbling" the melody over a demo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Duwz said:

honestly, it doesn't sound like Axl at all... and that's the first time i'd hear him "mumbling" the melody over a demo

In the same boat on you with this one. Sounds like Chesney

Edited by AxlRoseCDII
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

State of Grace 

When did you think you would tell me?

How long you think I could wait?

Oh no, but

I've got a notice that I'm all fine

Now I'm here back in your face now to let it in

 

 

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Duwz said:

honestly, it doesn't sound like Axl at all... and that's the first time i'd hear him "mumbling" the melody over a demo

Because a lot of these demos are recordings still in progress.  Bono does the same thing, mumbles or uses fake words in a work in progress melody  to later amnend with written lyrics

 

 

That is for sure Axl though, it is legit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, WhazUp said:

Because a lot of these demos are recordings still in progress.  Bono does the same thing, mumbles or uses fake words in a work in progress melody  to later amnend with written lyrics

 

 

That is for sure Axl though, it is legit.

For me it doesnt sound like Axl

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, WhazUp said:

Because a lot of these demos are recordings still in progress.  Bono does the same thing, mumbles or uses fake words in a work in progress melody  to later amnend with written lyrics

 

 

That is for sure Axl though, it is legit.

that's not news for me, I said I never heard AXL doing it, but thanks for explaining

 

also, the mix is a lot different from the other demos we heard... that means how the instruments and his voice sound together

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Finck2006 said:

For me it doesnt sound like Axl

Really? For me I can't imagine it being anyone but Axl!  His voice is sooo in "Live Era overdub" mode to me here haha.  He has an umistakable tone when he hits those higher, nearly-cracked high notes in that era similar to IRS

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Duwz said:

also, the mix is a lot different from the other demos we heard... that means how the instruments and his voice sound together

Probably because it is a more rough mix than any of the other songs such as the CD demos we got that had finished vocals.  Those were really getting to "release mode" at that point? this is probably more of a track expressing an idea as opposed to laying down final vocals or mixes

 

It is for sure Axl though, there are things that not even the best Axl soundalikes can replicate when it comes to specific nuances of when he does certain things

Edited by WhazUp

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, WhazUp said:

Probably because it is a more rough mix than any of the other songs such as the CD demos we got that had finished vocals.  Those were really getting to "release mode" at that point? this is probably more of a track expressing an idea as opposed to laying down final vocals or mixes

It is for sure Axl, and I can't imagine it not being a legit clip.  It is 100 percent him

A lot of the tracks on the Zutaut discs could be untouched from before Tom started working on the project - he could just have been keeping the most-complete versions of those tracks around for reference

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And remember too the '99 demos of TWAT and IRS that leaked years ago had worse fidelity than anything off the antiquiet leaks - all the pre-Zutaut stuff that's on Tom's locker discs might not have been mixed the same as the later stuff

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re; State of Grace snippet

The "face now" lyric at 0:11 is a direct rip of the IRS vocals imo.
"Now im sorry" at 0:08 is also taken from another Chi Dem song, but I cant put my finger on which one it is.

Calling bullshit on this one for the time being <_<

 

Edited by downliner

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To add onto my previous points too as to why I think this is for sure 100 percent legit:

-  Very similar vocals to IRS, same key (G, or concert F# if in standard tuning).  Axl-isms that are present all over Live Era's overdubbed vocals and CD vocals recorded from that time period.  Drum wise too, fills and grooves and drum-set tone very similar to what we have gotten from this batch so far

-  You can't stitch together clips seamlessly like that to make a totally new vocal melody unless you are one of the top audio engineers in the industry - even Evader's amazing General clip needed lots of different vocals going on at once in order to remotely fool the ear like the raspy part at the end of his clip

-  There has not been a single Axl impersonator that can come this close to sounding like Axl

And lastly, every single other clip and leak this past month that allegedly is coming from this same source of disks are all legitimate, there is precedent for legit GNR material coming out.  I just see no reason to believe that a clip that has unmistakably real Axl vox on it, is fake.  The only difference is this clip, has scratch vocals which is the first leak that has occurred on

Edited by WhazUp
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, downliner said:

Re; State of Grace snippet

The "face now" lyric at 0:11 is a direct rip of the IRS vocals imo.
"Now im sorry" at 0:08 is also taken from another Chi Dem song, but I cant put my finger on which one it is.

Calling bullshit on this one for the time being <_<

 

This isn't a fake, this exact snippet has been known to exist for weeks and it came from a trustworthy source

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can remember when people thought the Atlas clip was fake like it was yesterday...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, ApacheChief42 said:

This isn't a fake, this exact snippet has been known to exist for weeks and it came from a trustworthy source

I'm happy to be proved wrong :) F'n love your avatar Apache, one of my favourite albums. In fact Im gonna spin that now instead of this 13 seconds of gibberish :lol:

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, lukepowell1988 said:

How long in length is the SOG snippet?

13sec.

lyrics seem to be some temporary nananananaaa probably meant to just try how it sounds.

since this is the only version we know of, even if the whole thing leaks at some point, it's all we can hope for - nobody ever confirmed that any other version of SoG with vocals exists.

3. "STATE of GRACE" 3/27/00 (12) 4:00 (from Rough Mixes CD #3 tracklist)

 

interestingly, most of the songs leaked from this "era" come from the same date - just check this list - Quick Song is rumored to be floating somewhere, SoG as well, Prostitute that leaked last week might probably be also one of these... 3/27/00 sounds like an intriguing date :) 

4. "OKLAHAOMA" 3/23/00 (10) 4:12
1. "ME & MY ELVIS" 3/23/00 {#10} 5:40
3. "D TUNE" 3/23/00 {11} 5:16
4. "CURLY SHUFFLE" 3/23/00 {15} 3:43

5. "QUICKSONG" 3/27/00 (10) 4:00
3. "STATE of GRACE" 3/27/00 (12) 4:00
4. "PERHAPS" 3/27/00 {19} 3:56
6. "I.R.S." 3/27/00 (21) 4:14
5. "PROSTITUTE" 3/27/00 {23} 6:10
3. "ATLAS SHRUGGED" 3/27/00 {25} 4:12
7. "CATCHER" 3/27/00 {30} 5:35

7. "TONTO" 7/14/00 BLK/FRG dat (#3) 3:54

9. "SHANKLERS REVENGE" 9/14/00 cd (#1) 3:26
8. "REAL DOLL.com" 9/14/00 B. Head cd (#2) 4:04

2. "DUB SUPLEX" 10/05/00 BLK/FRG dat (#5) 3:02
5. "DEVIOUS BASTARD" 10/05/00 (#6) 3:26
8. "DUMMY" 10/05/00 (#8) 6:24

2. "T.W.A.T." 10/12/00 {#10} 5:10

1. "BILLIONARE" 10/15/00 BLK/FRG dat (#2) 1:31

9. "The BLUES" 10/23/00 {#6} 4:44

10. "I'm SORRY" 10/26/00 B. Head cd (#1) 6:00

1. "MADAGASCAR" 11/05/00 {Drum Adds} 5:37
8. "CHINESE DEMOCRACY" 11/05/00 {Ver.1} 3:12

6. "AS IT BEGAN" 11/07/00 {Ver.1} 3:51
2. "CIRCUS MAXIMUS" 11/07/00 {Ver.1} 4:30
2. "EYE ON YOU" 11/07/00 (VER.1) 3:36
3. "IF THE WORLD" 11/07/00 (VER.1) 5:05
4. "MUSTACHE" 11/07/00 (VER.1) 4:10
10. "SILKWORMS" 11/07/00 {Ver.1} 3:33
6. "RHIAD" 11/07/00 {Ver.1} 3:33

1. "P.R.L." 11/08/00 w/out THYME (no gtrs.) 3:54
5. "NOTHING" 11/08/00 {Ver.1} 3:50
7. "THYME" 11/08/00 {P.R.L.} 1:55
7. "HARDSCHOOL" 11/08/00 (12) NU AX 3:58
6. "ZODIAC 13" (no vox) 11/08/00 (VER.4) 4:38

Edited by zombux
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, AxlRoseCDII said:

In the same boat on you with this one. Sounds like Chesney

Oh no, no you don’t lol.

Don’t go dragging me into this 😂 this is NOTHING to do with me.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, 1418Music said:

Oh no, no you don’t lol.

Don’t go dragging me into this 😂 this is NOTHING to do with me.

Thanks for confirming that whoever it is, it's not you :lol:

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Lio said:

Thanks for confirming that whoever it is, it's not you :lol:

Glad to be of service😂.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×