Strange Broue Posted September 24, 2015 Share Posted September 24, 2015 And the only potential problem I see for Steven there is YCBM. Do you really believe that? Any decent drummer can play You Could Be Mine.Adler came up with the drums for YCBM. so there you go... i have always wondered about that... do you have any source for that?The song was written in '85 or '86. "Bitch slap rappin' and youre cocaine tounge" line was in the liner notes of Appetite, kind of as a teaser for the next album. Axl talks about it in an interview in 1990 or '91. oh, everybody knows that. that doesnt mean the song had that drum intro in 85 or 86.I guess im assuming a little bit there. I mean for the most part it looks as though Sorum came in and just did his version of Adlers parts. I thought i heard that the drum intro has always been there, dont remember from where though. Its not a complicated part though and theres no way that Steven would not be able to play it. Im a musician, not a drummer mind you, and i can play it. Its really not hard at all.So your original affirmation is based on nothing tangible.Both of you were wrongDuff came out with the drum intro fills.....YCBM was possibly not complete during the AFD days, at least not even on a demo form. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
curmudgeonrose Posted September 25, 2015 Share Posted September 25, 2015 (edited) 1. YOU COULD BE MINE!2. WELCOME TO THE JUNGLE!3. IT'S SO EASY!4, MR. BROWNSTONE!5. LIVE & LET DIE!6. CIVIL WAR!7. NOVEMBER RAIN!8. SWEET CHILD O' MINE!9. ESTRANGED!10. THERE WAS A TIME!11. YESTERDAYS!12. PATIENCE!13, ROCKET QUEEN!14. DON'T CRY!15. SO FINE!16. MY MICHELLE!17. 14 YEARS!18. MADAGASCAR!19. PARADISE CITY!20. NIGHTRAIN! Edited September 25, 2015 by curmudgeonrose Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ludurigan Posted September 25, 2015 Share Posted September 25, 2015 And the only potential problem I see for Steven there is YCBM. Do you really believe that? Any decent drummer can play You Could Be Mine.Adler came up with the drums for YCBM. so there you go... i have always wondered about that... do you have any source for that?The song was written in '85 or '86. "Bitch slap rappin' and youre cocaine tounge" line was in the liner notes of Appetite, kind of as a teaser for the next album. Axl talks about it in an interview in 1990 or '91. oh, everybody knows that. that doesnt mean the song had that drum intro in 85 or 86.I guess im assuming a little bit there. I mean for the most part it looks as though Sorum came in and just did his version of Adlers parts. I thought i heard that the drum intro has always been there, dont remember from where though. Its not a complicated part though and theres no way that Steven would not be able to play it. Im a musician, not a drummer mind you, and i can play it. Its really not hard at all.yeah i know it is not hard at all, yet a lot of people keep saying that steven cant play it... but anyway... i am not sure steven wrote that intro... i am sure it probably sounded great with him on drums! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ludurigan Posted September 25, 2015 Share Posted September 25, 2015 See I think KOHD is the worse offender. Those ''Dawwah'' and that phone overdub silliness. And when they did it live, they had the the ''give me some reggae'' bit and the whole thing dragged on so long that you were bored senseless. Axl doing his, ''you sing one, then i'll sing one'' - your the singer; I did not buy a ticket so that I should sing - for you! Woeful.i also couldnt stand that song on UYI tour after Izzy leftyou are right, the GIMME SOME REGGAE part was dreadfullwhat a fucking disgusting load of crapactually there was very little left of GNR after izzy left, but anywayfor great (terrific) knocking on Heavens Door live versions, you need to hear both rio 1991 versions and indiana 1991 versionfirst night in rio is funny because it was matts first gig with the band and he sorta misses the final partand axl goes- no no no no no no no, matt got a little excited there, bla bla bla,and they do it againand it just sounds fucking greatterrific soundboard quality, five guys playing rock n roll (oh wait, dizzy was there), crazy rio crowds (not the sanitized crowd that goes to rock in rio these days) and, very important, no GIMME SOMME REGGAE BULLSHIT Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stress Fracture Posted September 25, 2015 Share Posted September 25, 2015 (edited) Yeah having watched some drum covers on YouTube I'm sure Steven would be fine on YCBM. My thinking was influenced by performances where even Brain never quite sounded right on it. Edited September 25, 2015 by Stress Fracture Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
iceman51999 Posted September 25, 2015 Share Posted September 25, 2015 (edited) 1- Perfect Crime2- MR BrownstoneAXL RANT3- Its so Easy4- Night train5-YOU could be mine 6-YOure Crazy7- Out To get me AXL RANT8-KOHD9-AXL RANT 10-Drum solo11-SLASH SOLO12- AXL-Piano solo-Estranged13-Don't Cry14-Patience15--SLASH SOLO16-My Michelle17-Coma-18-LocomotiveAXL RANT19-Double Talking Jive20-Civil WARENCORE 21-Rocket Queen 22-Sweet Child O mine-AXL RANT23- November Rain24Paradise City What a gig ! Edited September 25, 2015 by iceman51999 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Philipm787 Posted September 26, 2015 Share Posted September 26, 2015 1.Jungle2.Brownstone3.Its so easy4.LALD5.Rocket queen6.Patience7.Civil war8.Beggars&hangers9.You're crazy10.Nightrain*Axl piano solo11.November rain12.TIL13.Fall to pieces14.YCBM*Slash solo15.My michelle16.Yesterdays17.BetterEncore 118.SCOM19.KOHD20.EstrangedEncore 221.Whole lotta Rosie22.Don't cry 23.Paradise city Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nosaj Thing Posted September 26, 2015 Share Posted September 26, 2015 "Axl Rant" 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
circusboy666 Posted September 26, 2015 Share Posted September 26, 2015 1-wttj2-iso3-brownstone4-cd5-better6-lald7-ycbm8-irs9-blues10-yesterday's11-November rain12-my Michelle 13-you're crazy14-out to get me15-don't cry16-estrangedEncore117-twat18-locomotiveEncore219-night train 20-patience21-paradise city Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jordan Rose Posted September 26, 2015 Share Posted September 26, 2015 If New Guns ever do reunite i'd like to see a short tour with the whole of Chines played plus Locomotive, Estranged, Breakdown, So Fine, 14 Years and Don't Cry Alt. Then they can release the next record and swap out some of the songs for new ones. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gibbo Posted September 26, 2015 Share Posted September 26, 2015 And the only potential problem I see for Steven there is YCBM. Do you really believe that? Any decent drummer can play You Could Be Mine.Adler came up with the drums for YCBM. so there you go... i have always wondered about that... do you have any source for that?The song was written in '85 or '86. "Bitch slap rappin' and youre cocaine tounge" line was in the liner notes of Appetite, kind of as a teaser for the next album. Axl talks about it in an interview in 1990 or '91. oh, everybody knows that. that doesnt mean the song had that drum intro in 85 or 86.I guess im assuming a little bit there. I mean for the most part it looks as though Sorum came in and just did his version of Adlers parts. I thought i heard that the drum intro has always been there, dont remember from where though. Its not a complicated part though and theres no way that Steven would not be able to play it. Im a musician, not a drummer mind you, and i can play it. Its really not hard at all.So your original affirmation is based on nothing tangible.Both of you were wrongDuff came out with the drum intro fills.....YCBM was possibly not complete during the AFD days, at least not even on a demo form. 1.40 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
muresan Posted September 27, 2015 Share Posted September 27, 2015 A good UYI era set list + Better and Street of Dreams. Catcher if they put work into it and TWAT if they add a second lead guitarist. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stress Fracture Posted September 27, 2015 Share Posted September 27, 2015 Besides, of the songs on my setlist, I'm now thinking Double Talkin' Jive is the harder song for Steven, especially compared to Matt's live performances. Not saying he can't do it, just like I never said he couldn't do You Could Be Mine, merely that it's one where he might come off as inferior to Machine Sorum.DTJ has to be played in any reunion show. Izzy gets a vocal, Slash gets an extended solo segueing into Civil War, Axl gets to go off and choose which hat to wear next. No James Bond themes needed. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Todo Poderoso Timão Posted October 6, 2015 Share Posted October 6, 2015 No KOHD, No Live And Let Die, no Chinese Democracy, no This I Love, no Sorry.Bring back the Talkbox on Rocket Queen.I can't see Axl agreeing with a reunion without playing Chinese Democracy songs...Oh but I'd love them to play Better, Madagascar or Prostitute. I was talking about ChiDem the song, which is awful.Are you kidding? ChiDem, the song is the best song of the album! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tom2112 Posted October 6, 2015 Share Posted October 6, 2015 It wasn't impossible to imagine Duff agreeing to play ChiDem songs. And then he did just that.It is impossible to imagine Slash playing those songs, though. I bet the only way he'd play them is if Axl agreed to do VR or Conspirators songs, which Axl would never do.Doesn't matter, this reunion will never happen. Sorry guys.But it's not the same thing. What's Slash's argument? Axl can just say that my songs were written under the gnr name, its a part of the bands history. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gordon Comstock Posted October 7, 2015 Share Posted October 7, 2015 Welcome to the JungleNightrainMr. BrownstoneCivil War(if Izzy is there: Dust N' Bones) or (if Izzy is not there: Attitude or New Rose)It's So EasyStreet of Dreams or This I LoveDouble Talkin' Jive-Slash SoloDon't Cry (stripped down version, like 2007)You Could Be MineNovember RainOut Ta Get MeSweet Child O MineNice BoysKnockin On Heavens Door (short version)Rocket Queen----------You're CrazyEstrangedParadise CityNo KOHD, No Live And Let Die, no Chinese Democracy, no This I Love, no Sorry.Bring back the Talkbox on Rocket Queen.I can't see Axl agreeing with a reunion without playing Chinese Democracy songs...Oh but I'd love them to play Better, Madagascar or Prostitute. I was talking about ChiDem the song, which is awful.Are you kidding? ChiDem, the song is the best song of the album!ChiDem the song is definitely in the bottom 5, it was a good song in 2002 but the intro, and especially the fretless guitar fucked up the album version. The antiquiet leak is probably the best version. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rocknroll41 Posted October 7, 2015 Share Posted October 7, 2015 Welcome to the JungleNightrainMr. BrownstoneCivil War(if Izzy is there: Dust N' Bones) or (if Izzy is not there: Attitude or New Rose)It's So EasyStreet of Dreams or This I LoveDouble Talkin' Jive-Slash SoloDon't Cry (stripped down version, like 2007)You Could Be MineNovember RainOut Ta Get MeSweet Child O MineNice BoysKnockin On Heavens Door (short version)Rocket Queen----------You're CrazyEstrangedParadise CityNo KOHD, No Live And Let Die, no Chinese Democracy, no This I Love, no Sorry.Bring back the Talkbox on Rocket Queen.I can't see Axl agreeing with a reunion without playing Chinese Democracy songs...Oh but I'd love them to play Better, Madagascar or Prostitute. I was talking about ChiDem the song, which is awful. Are you kidding? ChiDem, the song is the best song of the album! ChiDem the song is definitely in the bottom 5, it was a good song in 2002 but the intro, and especially the fretless guitar fucked up the album version. The antiquiet leak is probably the best version.The clip of the studio intro from the 2002 Boston Promo sounded even better than the Antiquiet leak actually. Too bad we never got a full version of that Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Todo Poderoso Timão Posted October 8, 2015 Share Posted October 8, 2015 Welcome to the JungleNightrainMr. BrownstoneCivil War(if Izzy is there: Dust N' Bones) or (if Izzy is not there: Attitude or New Rose)It's So EasyStreet of Dreams or This I LoveDouble Talkin' Jive-Slash SoloDon't Cry (stripped down version, like 2007)You Could Be MineNovember RainOut Ta Get MeSweet Child O MineNice BoysKnockin On Heavens Door (short version)Rocket Queen----------You're CrazyEstrangedParadise CityNo KOHD, No Live And Let Die, no Chinese Democracy, no This I Love, no Sorry.Bring back the Talkbox on Rocket Queen.I can't see Axl agreeing with a reunion without playing Chinese Democracy songs...Oh but I'd love them to play Better, Madagascar or Prostitute. I was talking about ChiDem the song, which is awful.Are you kidding? ChiDem, the song is the best song of the album!ChiDem the song is definitely in the bottom 5, it was a good song in 2002 but the intro, and especially the fretless guitar fucked up the album version. The antiquiet leak is probably the best version.Which one is exactly this antiquiet leak?Any link? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TeeJay410 Posted October 8, 2015 Share Posted October 8, 2015 Honestly pretty similar to the set lists they have been doing it. I have complained about the set in the past but all things considered it isn't bad. Maybe they could use some more illusions songs. I actually would like to see them hang on to one or two CD songs. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rocknroll41 Posted October 8, 2015 Share Posted October 8, 2015 Welcome to the JungleNightrainMr. BrownstoneCivil War(if Izzy is there: Dust N' Bones) or (if Izzy is not there: Attitude or New Rose)It's So EasyStreet of Dreams or This I LoveDouble Talkin' Jive-Slash SoloDon't Cry (stripped down version, like 2007)You Could Be MineNovember RainOut Ta Get MeSweet Child O MineNice BoysKnockin On Heavens Door (short version)Rocket Queen----------You're CrazyEstrangedParadise CityNo KOHD, No Live And Let Die, no Chinese Democracy, no This I Love, no Sorry.Bring back the Talkbox on Rocket Queen.I can't see Axl agreeing with a reunion without playing Chinese Democracy songs...Oh but I'd love them to play Better, Madagascar or Prostitute. I was talking about ChiDem the song, which is awful. Are you kidding? ChiDem, the song is the best song of the album! ChiDem the song is definitely in the bottom 5, it was a good song in 2002 but the intro, and especially the fretless guitar fucked up the album version. The antiquiet leak is probably the best version.Which one is exactly this antiquiet leak?Any link?No sorry, I don't have the Antiquiet files, just heard them on YouTube back when they first leaked but they were gone by the end of the year when the actual record came out.It was 9 songs that leaked from that Antiquiet site. And overall, that was my favorite version of the album. Not too choppy and as demo-sounding as the MSL leaks from 2006, and yet not as overproduced sounding as the final album. The bassline on TWaT was louder and better-sounding. Riad didn't have that silly effects intro and had a better solo from Bucket instead of Bumble. The drums on CD, Better, and ITW were still from Brain and therefore blended better with everything else. CD itself just had the low vocals and keyboards in the verses, making it much easier to listen to imo (less sore on the ears, if that makes sense). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Majestic Beast Posted October 8, 2015 Share Posted October 8, 2015 1. Silkworms2. Silkworms3. Silkworms4. Silkworms5. Drum Solo6. Silkworms7. Pitman Solo8. Slash Solo9. Silkworms 10. Oh My GodThis is a playback dj setlist with mappet show members to appear? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
wasted Posted October 9, 2015 Share Posted October 9, 2015 I just think Izzy, Duff, Slash will reignite some GNR classics that they used to do. And that will be the set list. If its Vegas Residency for 30th Anni of AFD would any mind if they just played AFD all the way through with a few off Lies? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DeadSlash Posted October 14, 2015 Share Posted October 14, 2015 I know some of you don't want anything but the original material, and that's fine, just buy Live Era, but for the rest of us:What are the solo project songs you would like to see done by a reunion lineup? I have a few I'd really like to see. Keep in mind it's not a thread about what they "would do" or if they "should do" any of the solo stuff, just a simple question of what would you like to see them do with a GnR slant.Beggars and Hangers-On: Axl on vocals.Shuffle It All: Izzy on vocalsSlither or Set me Free: Axl on vocalsMan in the meadow with Axl on vocals, but I think if they did anything from the Duff album, it would be The Punk Rock Song, it has Axl's vocals written all over it.TWAT or Chinese Democracy with Slash's take on the solo's.(If Gilby then) Cure Me or Kill me. Gilby on vocals.I'm sure if I thought about it harder, I'd come up with more, but the top 2 would leave me disappointed if they didn't happen.I was thinking of different Slash ft. Myles Kennedy & The Conspirators stuff, but I'm not a huge of Myles vocals, so I think I'd like to hear Axl's vocals on any of it, but if I had to choose one, I'd probably take You're a Lie. Not because it is my favorite song from those albums, I just think the band would play it really well and Axl would sound great on the vocals for it. It sounds like it could have been written for GnR. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mendez Posted October 14, 2015 Share Posted October 14, 2015 (edited) Let It Roll, verses seem very its so easy esque.Everyone on Upside by IzzySlash & Izzy on Catcher & Riad Edited October 14, 2015 by Mendez Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
wasted Posted October 14, 2015 Share Posted October 14, 2015 I Hate Everybody But You seemed like it had potential. Izzy has a lot that could be worked on. Time Gone ByAin't that a BitchOld HatBombJust Don't KnowRiver Boxall have something that could be GNR. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts